People tell me all the time, they're you happy? You truly like what you do? What I tell people is the truth. If you're not happy in automotive, you know, we're really in the people this. And if you can't find a place where you feel like you belong and can make a difference, I think that's your problem. And if you like people, it's terrific.
What's up everyone? This is Car D'Oeship Guy. You're listening to the Car D'Oeship Guy podcast, which is my effort to give you access to the most unbiased and transparent insights into the car market.
Let's get into today's episode. Brett Morgan is CEO of Morgan Auto Group, the second largest private car dealership group in the country consisting of 66 dealerships. To put it bluntly, this was one of the most interesting conversations I've had on the CDP podcast. We discussed acquiring 60 dealerships in under seven years, dealership profitability, how Brett compensates his management team, raising kids into generational wealth, paying over $200 million for a single Toyota dealership, while only drive one type of vehicle. His blunt message to the CEO of Ford, Jim Farley, the future and challenges with EVs, and truthfully, so, so much more. I recommend you listen very closely because Brett drops lots of gems.
But before we dive into the show, theft is plaguing dealerships nationwide, losing car keys as an unneeded cost, and searching for keys can lead to bottlenecks in the sales process. Keeper systems has the solution for dealers. The Keeper MX is the number one key control solution in the auto industry, handling millions of transactions per day. It features a 16-gauge steel cabinet with a built-in camera and a puck-lock for additional safety, along with many other features so that dealers can know who took a key when and why. Keeper systems has been in the auto industry for over 40 years and is at over 12,000 dealerships, offering exclusive key control for 6 out of 10 biggest automotive groups in the world. They have a wide range of products that fit the needs of franchise dealers, independent dealers, and even the smallest pre-owned lots. New customers can take advantage of my partnership with Keeper systems right now to receive an exclusive discount. All you need to do is visit Keepersystems.com, click on the car dealership guide link, and fill out the form to receive 25% off your first key machine purchase. Or if you prefer to call just mention car dealership guide to receive your discount. Keepersystems.com, keypersystems.com.
Wasted data is a serious issue in automotive, but data is the key to driving revenues which means some dealers out there are just ignoring a goldmine that is staring them in the face. Let's face it, most dealerships are completely overrun with data silos. None of the data sources are integrated with each other, leaving the data as a jumbled mess instead of a clean set that could be turning into cash. Fullpath solves this by gathering, cleaning, and sorting your data into one platform so you can use it to speak to your customers' needs with killer AI-powered marketing campaigns. My friends over at Fullpath are breaking barriers, and I'm really excited to have them as a partner of the podcast. I believe in their product and more importantly, intermission to help dealers grow. Fullpath can help you turn your data into dollars, find them at fullpath.com.
Rhett Morgan on the CDG podcast, Brett. How are you? A car dealership guide. It's great to see you. Great to be here with you. Just a conversation we had over in Alaska a couple of minutes, man. I wish that was part of this podcast, but we'll get to a lot of juicy stuff. I'm pumped for this.
Before we get started, give us your background. I thought Morgan Autogroup, this colossal behemoth for lack of a better term, was your family's first act. I came to discover doing my research as actually a second or maybe a fifth or six or whatever act. I saw Tires Plus and I had no idea that that was a creation of the Morgan family. We'd love to hear about that and your family's start in the business world.
That's great. I would say this, it really feels like Morgan automotive from the narrative or my father's perspective, Larry Morgan. It's really his third entrepreneurial venture. His first was a family business with another family. That was Merchants' Tire and Auto Service Centers out of the Mid-Atlantic. I grew up not the son of a car dealer, but the son of somebody in the Independent Tire and Auto Service space. He helped grow that family business for the Merchants from three retail to 166. That was my childhood.
At the age of around 11, 91 or 92, the family had a shake up. There had been some marriages, some deep blood had come into the family. He was turbanate. It was a crazy memory for me as a young guy because I think my dad tells this story where I told one of my friends, his father had gotten laid off. I was like, that's okay. My dad got laid off too. My dad heard me say this and he was laughing about it at the time until this day. That was a big springboard for him to think about entrepreneurship and being in his own deal.
Did you guys have any entrepreneurial genes in the family or was Morgan Auto Group and Tires Plus an outcome from building and having a growing appetite to have a bigger impact and get bigger? It's probably a better question for my father. He's always been in business, always wanted to be in business. Lives, eats, drinks, breathes, the entrepreneurial dream, the American dream, if you will. His story is common tail of some of these legendary figures that walk around the business landscape today.
Going back to that time in 92, when he was terminated, he reconnected with an old mentor of his from Firestone, a guy named Donaldson, who had, I think, called 25, 30 retail shops out of the Clearwater, Florida area, which is kind of a part of what I call the Tri-City area here in Tampa, Tampa Bay, St. Pete Clearwater. He came down and was going to be an investor. That turned out, he borrowed the capital and bought that business when I was 12 years old.
What would you say from your perspective, and before we get deeper into your story, what keeps your father motivated at this point? From what I understand, he's still involved in the business, very involved. I'm not sure exactly his age and stage in life, but what keeps him motivated at this point? The reality is, he, I think, gets highly motivated from watching other people be able to accomplish more in their life than they ever had been able to previously or ever been able to imagine. I think for him, a large part of that drive is watching other people grow and succeed. This is certainly financially, but also in their means to be able to lead others.
Have you guys ever discussed an exit strategy or succession? What does that look like for the family? Again, you're operating the second largest private-cardular group in the country. Correct me if I'm wrong. This isn't a mom and pop shop on the side of the street. What can you share with that? When you run something this big, how do you think about generational wealth and passing that on and keeping the likes you go? Yeah, it's funny. It's fascinating because at some point, dad's story is going to meet my story. The reality of life is there's probably some jokes in the car business that by the third generation, it's time to sell. There's reasons for that. You see, and I think even one of your past guests kind of touched on those reasons why generational businesses trade hands, even though they are tremendously cash generating incredible generational growth opportunities, why people get out of the car business.
We were very fortunate. Don Olson, that business, became Tires Plus. The Tires Plus name came through an acquisition from a Minnesota Minneapolis based company owned by a guy named Tom Gigax. Then Larry took that name and ran with it with his growing operation. He grew Donald Olson tire from 30 retail or whatever it was to 650 under the Tires Plus banner. Some of that was through acquisition. A lot of that was fresh brick and mortar builds too in growing markets. It was a little bit above, I think, a real education form that has served Morgan well.
By this point, how many years have been CEO of Morgan Autogroup? That transition was 2016, which is a pretty. You've been CEO for, say, seven plus years, you've acquired countless stores under yourself. The group has grown and you've done incredible. We'll get into the details shortly.
I'm trying to really think about the psychology of you growing up under your dad's businesses and getting some involvement. Was there a period where you felt like, you had this chip on your shoulder like, oh, I'm like one of those sons in the business that kind of people think got into through my dad. Yeah, so I'll talk about that. The industry has terminology for that. It's called PhD. Papa has a dealership. I know a different term, but I don't think it's a car dealership guy appropriate.
Well, it's funny because I never heard that term. The opportunity to get in the car business with dad out of college, I worked for Clear Channel, which is now, of course, I, I was on the programming side. Which, by the way, that blew me away that you've been in media. So I had no idea.
Yeah, I just, I loved it. I've got a creative side to me. I was on the programming side. I was not on the sales side. I did three years at Clear Channel, Richard, or two and a half years. We're out some fascinating times. You know, SS Cole bombing, DC sniper 911. I mean, I was there for some really fascinating stuff. Yeah, some good stuff.
And then, you know, dad had sold Larry sold Piers Plus and he tried to retire. And he went and like, you know, hit golf balls for a few weeks and noticed his game wasn't improving. And he was just like, he's just not a man to sit still. And a friend of his name, Ed Lieberwitz, was on a local back then it was Sun Trust, now truest bank, Florida board with them. And Ed was, I think, you know, he had married into the Bremen family. And then I don't know if you know what Norman Bremen is, but huge heritage South Florida dealer, former owner of the Philadelphia Eagles, you know, talk about another great story and automotive.
So anyway, Ed in his son-in-law, got him, Jason Hian, were looking to buy some car stores. They'd been involved in a few dealerships locally. Ended up buying a Honda Volkswagen store in Tampa. And you know, dad was a silent minority partner. And he talked to me, you know, hey, it's good money making opportunities and interesting business. It's got some, you know, some maybe a little bit more excitement than the traditional, you know, tire and auto service, you know, space and maybe you should come down sell cars and, you know, figure it out. I got to, you know, frankly, you know, I think I came down to Florida and put the car back on the auto train and got it back to Richmond and the new car smelling glue of the facade.
I think it got to my head because in three weeks, I was like, I'm coming down to Tampa. I'm selling cars. So my college roommate could play basketball at Richmond. I recruited him and we came down a couple months later and started selling cars at the speed of the console. So that was the foray into the the dealership world. Right.
Yeah. So going back to that chip on the shoulder, right? Like, did you have those moments people are like, oh, this guy's one to sperm lottery? Yeah, early on, I could kind of see it. See, but then I have a chip on my shoulder. Yes. It turned into maybe a problem. So yeah, it became, I'll never forget my one of my earliest mentors in this business. And this was at our next store, the second store I worked in just one day looked at me and goes, look, kid, I get it. You'll pop the floor, you know, you'll sell the tires and put them on, you know, you'll, you'll stay here until midnight at night. Like, stop, like, stop. Like, let's, let's talk about how we can work smarter. Let's talk about where you're going. And in this constant need to prove yourself is doing you a disservice.
Do you think as a father, do you think you would follow the same type of path that you did with your dad? And, you know, would you want your, your daughter, your, your, any future children, would you want them to get into the business to work from a young age? I think, you know, I've had to reconcile that I've had other opportunities that other people had, didn't have, even if it's working in a tire warehouse. So yeah, I think, you know, Publix isn't going to hire a 12 year old, whether I like it or not, right? They're just not. So I think I don't regret being a part of the family business, even in that, you know, in that respect going back to the age of 12. I think work ethic is important. And I think if you're an entrepreneur and you have a vehicle to expose someone to that existence, I think it's extremely healthy.
So now what I probably wouldn't do is be having conversations with a 15 year old or my daughter hypothetically someday about, yeah, this is all going to be yours someday. And, you know, it's just, it's too much, it's, it's too much pressure. You know, I love to Alan's story on your podcast about the, what the guy became like a jazz promoter after his dad sold the business. Yeah. Yeah. Like everyone, everyone secretly wants to be a rock star anyway.
People tell me all the time, they're, are you happy? Do you, you know, do you truly like what you do? And what I tell people is the truth. If you're not happy in automotive, there is such a variety of, you know, we're really in the people business, but there are so many angles. And this, it's a really complex, simple business. And if you can't find a place where you feel like you belong and can make a difference, I think that's your problem. That doesn't mean I've loved every job I've ever had in this business. But I just think it's great. And I, you know, I've kind of relished a lot of the opportunities I've had in it, but it's just fascinating. And if you like people, it's terrific.
What was the journey like leading up to being, becoming CEO of the company? Tell me about that. Yeah, so my career path, automotive specific. So I don't discount, you know, the little time I spent as a, you know, writing service in an independent sire, tire and service shop, because that, that was a good experience. And I think relative to a dealership experience. So, you know, I sold cars for two, two and a half years. I met an incredible guy named Ross Bauer. He's still in our industry, but on the vendor side now, he was my general sales manager. And he kind of wrote my career plan. And I think it's a pretty common one that a lot of dealerships, at least at the time, had kind of been here too. So I started in sales, then I became a floor manager, went from floor manager to an internet director. And obviously back in, you know, whenever that was 2005, that meant something a little different than what it does today. Just because ecom has become, you know, so much more important part of our business. I rolled out of that experience into F and I financed that into use car management. So, and I think his thinking was you need that finance understanding as far as, you know, how to get deals bought, subprime, et cetera, to be able to work the desk of a use car department. And then I went to use cars.
And then we had acquired, I think our third and fourth store in our CFO, he was a good old Georgia boy, Russell Rass calls me one day and he goes, I can't get your daddy's attention. But this, this dealership we just bought eight months ago is drowning in inventory. And somebody, somebody don't wake up, it's gonna drown all of us. So I went up and talked to Russell. And look, there's parts of the business that, that Larry Morgan was learning what I was. It was really exciting times. I mean, 20, the 20 group experience was very formidable to us understanding the car business. And I even haven't even really gotten into how that happened. But anyway, I ended up going to Gainesville, Florida, we had bought a Pontiac Buick GMC store and a Honda store to kind of do a health check. And it was a disaster. I think we'd own the store for a year. There were cars, there were used cars every year, all there was a use, there's a used cars that were nine months old, still had a G, you know, GMAC smart auction stickers on them hadn't been reconned. You know, new car inventory out a year, you know, set being a many units out a year and a half. CIT contracts and transit, receivables issues on wholesale, contracts and transit out 90 days. It was a dumpster fire.
And we bought, we bought this Pontiac store because it came, you know, the Honda store was really the, they had the pearl, the pearl in that deal. And we'd left the, the operator who was there previously in the Pontiac store. And we wondered when we bought it, why the previous dealer principal had his office in the messy old dilapidated Pontiac store and not the nice new Honda store down the street. Well, there was your answer. You know, he needed that oversight. The other guy was a retailer, but he wasn't a general manager. And I ended up going there for like, what I thought would be a couple weekends. And I left Gainesville three and a half years later. Wow.
And that was what did you do? You took, you took over as GM at the time. I initially took over as GSM. I kind of had some influence over who the GM was and then the recession. So I'd, I'd been there for a short time and then kind of, you know, oh, wait, oh, nine was happening.
I think any person that you speak with that has been successful in the car business and honestly any business that requires, you know, some creativity, but whatnot. But I've had a very similar experience where you sort of get thrown into situations and you have to be a chameleon. That's what I call it. You know, you kind of have to figure it out. And those are the people that are scrappy that are able to kind of multiple situations. And you know, hey, guess what, this store needs your help. And like you said, three and a half years later, you're there, you're still there. Or whatever it may be, this department that, you know, that department, it's that's the people that seem to be elevated most in this business from what I've seen. And also from my experience, that was what brought a lot of value being able to kind of put out those fires, but then build on top of that and prove yourself in a new department and just be a problem solver. And again, it gave me confidence.
You know, so ultimately, it's funny, I joke that I knew my dad loved me because when I first asked him if I could take over the store, because they were going to fire the GM and I was going to come back to Tampa. And I thought about it all night. And, you know, we were still kind of in the thick of the recession. And I called my dad the next day and said, let me have it. And I joke that I really knew my dad loved me because his answer was, let me think about it. And he really did.
And I think the store had lost year to date $476,000. And we made maybe $280,290 the following year or something. What year was this? Actually, you know what, it was a $1.2 million turnaround. So this was, you know, 2010, I think. So it was a $1.2 million turnaround. So I think the store had lost something like 800, you know, called 800,000 and we made 400 the next year. And man, it was a grind, you know, we that was a Pontiac, obviously, you know, went away at that time, cash for clunkers. But that was our inexpensive new car to retail. So our, you know, our new car cost a good soul. Our cost of sale went to like 39 grand overnight between the GMC truck product and, you know, Buick on claves. And we were basically infinity dealers and, you know, heavily subprime Gainesville, Florida, it's a college town. They don't, they don't want to drive, you know, G sixes and it was just a grind. And, you know, GM was kind of trying to retool the Buick lineup to get some lower cost, you know, vehicles into that new car side.
And you can, you know, when you're selling 50 new cars a month, you know, in that market doing, you know, heavy subprime, you're not trading for a lot of vice things. So we were trying to sell two to, you know, two to one use to new. And I'd say 95% of our inventory was purchase car. And you just, you know, it lived this existence. So I don't need to tell you, you know, little margins on the used car side and cry over a deal. You know, you've got it. And you've got a Chevy dealer across the street who sells the same products, your GMC, you know, your GMC does. So it's, even for a single point market, it came with some disadvantages in that store.
And then good. Yeah, it was 2010. And then I, how many stores that you have then, how many stores do you guys have then 2010?
然后好。是的,那是在2010年。然后我,你们那时候有多少家店呢?2010年的时候你们有多少家店?
To 2010, probably five or six. Got it. And today you are at 66. 66. Got it.
到2010年,可能是五六岁。明白了。而今天你已经六十六岁了。六十六岁。明白了。
What are you doing nowadays? How many cars are you selling per year, renew versus now?
你现在在做什么?你每年销售多少辆汽车,与现在相比有多少更新?
Okay. So, you know, we, I think last year we did 137,000 total. This year, I think we're trending like 165,000, something along those lines, new and used total.
So like a trailing 12 months, I can remember it. So like at the end of Q1 was like 8.4 billion. And we're going to be knocking on the door of nine billion. Nine billion in revenue.
I think in terms of even out, you know, I, sure, even out. Yeah, nine and a half percent, even on margin, you know, we stack ourselves next to the publics. You know, we look at all their numbers. Yeah. We're, we're on top of most, you know, certainly right in the thick from a total net margin perspective. And we do things all differently than they do. So, so yeah, we're, we're drives that. I mean, why, why are you on top of most and like, give me the benchmarks. Go ahead. You said you do things differently. I'm curious.
Well, I, I say we do, I, we're just built a little differently, right? You have that auto nation model and it was, you know, even Allen discussed it on a couple of pods ago with you, you know, which, you know, hey, you know, we've got this corporate support team or this management company support. We're going to go get a GM and he's not responsible truly for everything. So we're going to pay in less and we don't, you know, we pay, we pay top dollar at every position. Even COVID, post COVID, you know, I remember sitting, you know, on a rewards trip in Bologna, Italy with one of the executives from one of the publics and he was bragging about putting in these salary caps on his GMs. Well, they didn't make all that money. Like, you know, it's, I'm like, what does that budgeting for the next year look like? You're trying to raise the bar or get the guy to look at it, you know, a different level of achievement, but you put in, you know, you basically put a restrictor plate on them. Good bad and indifferent, we feel differently. We're going to be at the, you know, the uttermost, you know, top rankings of, you know, competition on on pay plans.
We're very decentralized. That does it mean that's the point I was just going to get at you. It sounds like you're very you run a very decentralized model, which is good and bad. You know, the great part is why we do it. We want our leaders and we have some minority partners too. We want them to feel completely empowered to the environment that they're inside of. We want them to feel like their partners, even when they're not, even when they don't have skin in the game. And we want them to feel like their hands are on all the levers that can, you know, participate in success. And we take anything that we do from a centralized management company level, we don't take lightly. Because if it adds expense in the store, that's going to lessen our ability to hold those operators accountable. You know, I mean, you walk into some even, you know, single point, small family dealerships. You just you've talked to the operator and he's going, you know, I've got these, you know, miscellaneous fees, these management fees, I'm paying for the jet. I'm paying for the, you know, the tickets of the game. I'm paying for this. I can't control my my advertised, they own their own advertising company. I'm not allowed to choose this. I'm not allowed to do that. And at the end of the day, you've basically got a desk manager running a car store sometimes. And we feel very differently. We've done a lot to protect that.
Now, having said that, as business evolves, our guys have needed our support and our help. And we realized a long time ago that being a GM is more than really any one person can accomplish. So we did start to build kind of supplemental, you know, help, not just supervision. We have regional platform managers. We have what we call use car regional directors. We have what we call e-commerce directors that help facilitate the operations at the store level. We have a team of fixed operations, kind of consultants that work with our service managers and our, we've got, you know, technician recruiters. We've got two teammates that kind of facilitate the budgeting of our marketing spend in each store. And you know, and most of these folks have 12 to 15 stores each. In the case of our marketing team, I mean, they're split down the middle. They've got 33 stores a piece. It's a lot. We ask a lot of our people. We pay them very well.
And but it does give that. What's pay them well? What is an average GM make? Don't I don't want to go like too high, too low, just like average, you know, you 66 stores. Right. What does that look like? Well, let's do the math. So last, you know, trailing 12 months, you know, at the end of Q1, I think our net profit called 800 million dollars, right? We buy that by 66. I'm not that good. Oh, we got we got 12. Let's just say 12, roughly. Right. So yeah, you know, yeah. So in we pay our guys kind of the industry standard, and we, you know, look, there might be some allowances here and there, but you know, it's it's so 10 grand a month in salary and 10% of the net. Got it. So 12 is a roughly 12 million a store, 10% and a small salary. We have a lot of people make a lot of money. I'm sure you do.
One thing that comes to mind is being a decentralized model, I mean, on a much smaller scale than you, but I've tested, you know, multiple models throughout the years and just, you know, with different types of autonomy and independence versus kind of corporate support, it seems like how do you even do it, right? And what at your scale being like, how do you run a decentralized model at such a scale without, you know, having these, you know, single points of failure or other things just kind of break down.
I mean, there's a reason people go to a decentralized model, right? It's for, you know, processes, having, you know, systems, things that are sort of ingrained and make it easier to manage and scale and have more predictability. But how do you do it? And again, I'm sure it comes down to the people, but like how it's, you know, it's all people. And again, it's, you know, we give people enough support where if they don't know the answer or they don't have that specific process or they don't, you know what I mean? It's there. There's a playbook there for our operators, but if he wants to run a different system or run a, you know, in a different manner, we don't universally, you know, support like I can think and again, maybe this is more relevant 15 years ago than today, but like an up system, you know, there's software that will, you know, rotate consumers amongst your sales floor. We've never mandated anything like that. If somebody wants to run, you know, have an internal BDC, they can have an internal BDC as long as we approve the budget and it works within our confines and the stores succeeding on, we've kind of have four pillars, right?
So low turnover, right? So we're, we're people, animals, we manage our turnover. You know, people don't follow rules. They follow leaders. So, you know, turnover is a direct reflection of that, that leader's ability. If the stores are, are, you know, sales efficient, if their CSI is in good standing with the manufacturer, and then lastly, if they're on budget, and you know, our budget's kind of our Bible and that's gotten really complicated in kind of the post-COVID days. But we start in late November building out templates and we have, you know, great accounting team in the peripheral and an incredible kind of what I call chief financial analyst and then a few people under our COO and then our entire executive team gets together, works with these operators and we bang out this year, it'll be 66 budgets at about two weeks. And I mean, we go from eight in the morning to eight nights. So you're looking for, yeah.
And so as a GM, you're looking for, you want me to have low turnover. You want me to have a strong customer service index rating, right, for the audience. It's listening and you want to pretty much deliver a good customer service and get, you know, good ratings from the customers. And then you want it to hit
budget, right? Do any of these incentivize bad behavior? For example, right? Like when I think about low turnover, is anyone throwing money at the problem, maybe exceeding budget to reduce turnover? Sure. Always. Always. For each, you know, for each action, there's an equal, not a passive reaction. My brain is right away thinking about how can the system be game? No. Well, you, and you're not wrong. And you probably think like, are you should be one of our operators?
You know, it's funny, years ago, I can remember, we're just very, so we're very transparent. So every one of our operators can see every single other one of our operators financial statements. I mean, it's all right there for it. You know, if you're part of our organization, leadership, you see it all. And the same thing from a traffic management perspective. So you can, you know, you can tell me what, you know, if you're sitting in Naples, Florida, you know what our big hottest or our two big hot stores in Tampa are closing on their econ traffic and on four lead submissions, you know, all that information.
And it's funny, because when we first started to kind of promote and, you know, community, you know, in the past, you could just go to the CRM and get that data for your store. But when we started kind of holding it up to the light for everyone to see, man, we had people right and left trying to game the system. And they would take in, you know, quality leads and try to reclassify them to get them out of their account to raise their clothes, right? So look, I mean, always, you're always going to get that. And you have to be really careful on what drum you're banging on. Because if it has, you know, a knee jerk reaction that can negatively affect that customer experience, you know, profitability can't be your God, or your God, you know, there or all the time.
I love that. I mean, this is the, this is that nitty gritty of dealing, right? With people and incentivizing management. And I love the transparency. I think that's huge, especially, you know, in this business, you know, a lot of many deals, you don't operate like that. And so it's really great that you just show that, show that between the operators. And you know, you create that competition, but of course, you know, there are other side effects.
Tell me another thing. When we think about, you know, getting to 66 stores, what do you look for in an acquisition? I mean, you guys have grown like a weed. It's been super impressive. You've remained private. I want to talk about how you funded everything as well.
Yeah. What do you look for in an acquisition? Like what are the kind of core pillars you're looking for? Are you looking for value add? Are you looking just to add cash flow? What is it for you?
Yeah. So look, they all, they all have to stand on their own. And what I mean by that is I think if you get too formulaic, if it has to meet a particular criterion or specific formula, I think they can get you into trouble. You know, not everything that we bought, we bought because we saw tremendous upside, you know, there was low hanging fruit. Or we bought it because we just, we love the brand.
I mean, there was a time, you know, luxury stores are hard to find in Florida because AutoNation was founded here. And some of the other publics have a pretty good, you know, foothold. So if you look at like a percentage of revenue of Morgan versus the public's, we're at like 19% of our current revenue, it comes from luxury participating luxury dealerships. The rest is, you know, domestic and import. But if you look at the public, I think there's only one under 40% of revenue coming from luxury. And that's Asbury and the rest are all over 40%. So for years, we were kind of conscience of, hey, whatever we could grab that makes really good sense in the luxury space, that would be, that would be nice to have further diversifies us, gets us into some new brands. Typically, the margins are a little bit better on some of the luxury product. Of course, you know, there's always a yin and yang, right? Who's been, who's Tesla been banging on? So the luxury legacy manufacturers.
So I can also remember at a time where like, you know, luxury was maybe two or 4% of, you know, our total, total generated revenue. So there's times we do get maybe strategic. There's markets we'd love to have more throughput in Orlando, South Florida, you know, we've only been in South Florida for I think the past four, four years. You know, Jacksonville is a market that I think is, you know, will continue to grow. It would be a good market for us to be in. We dominate here in Tampa. We've got I think 23 retail and, you know, Tampa, Sarasota, we love Southwest Florida. We've got good throughput there. So you're really looking, you're, you're pretty much saying, hey, it's store by store basis. And, you know, you treat them all independently. You look at the opportunity. It's got a pencil too. It does have to pencil. So, you know, again, it's a, it's a, it's a sounds like the Warren Buffett mantra. No, buy, buy great businesses that are mispriced or whatever. However, he says that.
Yeah, or, or fundamentally, they just have different priorities. You know, a very common tale in our business is, you know, generational car dealers. And I think, you know, Allen talked about this a little bit, you know, generational car dealers that did a great job of selling new cars. They serve the factory extremely well. They were very conservative, in used cars and maybe potentially F and I. And, you know, they don't have what we have, which is, you know, interwoven into our fixed operations, which for people listening, when I say fixed operations, I mean, service parts, body shop, is, you know, that independent streak, that independent flair, you know, I think Larry told automotive news in his first interview with the back and I go five that he used to steal customers from the franchise dealers. And now he's trying to get him back. And I thought that was so funny, because it's so true, right? Why do people go to a jiffy lube or an independent sometimes because of miseducation, but it's usually over how they're treated. Yeah, they want to save money. Yeah, they want to save money. They want to save money. Oh, yeah. Why go to the franchise dealer? You can, why pay the certified pre-owned markup, where you could buy a used car from us. That's reconditioned just as well. Yeah, see, I mean, you who hasn't used that line? You kind of live that existence on the retail side.
So that's a very common tale. Somebody who's just been a really good new car dealer.
这是一个非常常见的故事。有人只是一个非常出色的新车经销商。
So we look at their business, and we're thankful they have that customer base and that throughput, but we're going, hey, what if we did one to one, we could do one to one new to use? And Al Henderson, you brought it up again on the big boy. That's not for anyone listening. Al Henderson, that's the Toyota store that I tweeted about that. We're going on a group just recently purchased.
因此,我们关注他们的业务,并感谢他们拥有那样的客户群和产能,但是我们在考虑,嘿,如果我们做一个对一个的,我们可以实现一个对一个的新用户使用吗? Al Henderson,你在大家面前提到了这个话题。这并不是给任何正在听的人听的。Al Henderson是那家我在推特上提到的丰田店。最近我们刚刚收购了这个集团。
Yeah, according to Alan, it was the largest blue sky, not multiple, largest blue sky. Again, for people listening. Enterprise, that's just a value on the goodwill of the dealership. On the revenue.
And it was so exciting. I'll never forget the day where we're all sitting down, executive team, and we're just kind of talking through it, and we're working through our pro formas. And we had, I think, three revisions of the pro forma, and we're all sitting here, and then it came time to, and it's funny, because sometimes, well, we don't involve the whole team in the what's the offer going to be, but this one was different. So we did.
And it was just great, because I mean, just numbers that in my mind was struggle, really struggling. I mean, I just knew kind of what the number was going to have to be to earn that deal. But I had such content, like, who, I think at the time, I would tell people who doesn't want people within our office, who doesn't want just a big, strong asset, like Al Hendrickson Toyota.
And what I mean by that is, even though Toyota, I think they're on the bottom end of the spectrum from a day supplies perspective. But you look at the customer, what they want, they want Toyota. Toyota has been able to somehow, they've struggled a little bit getting inventory to the dealers, but it hasn't hurt the consumers want, well, and desire for their products.
And you know, my second existence in the dealership world was in a Toyota store. And Southeast Toyota, again, for people listening who don't understand the nuances of the business, Southeast Toyota is the last private distribution ship in the United States of I think any, many, why does that matter? Because they're different.
It's just, it's, you get a little different flavor of that typical communication with the, with the manufacturer.
这只是因为你和制造商之间的典型沟通方式稍有不同,所以你会感受到一点不同的味道罢了。
Dealer. Yeah. And does that impact the consumer in any way? Is it like, you know, more availability for inventory? I think so. I think so. Because you have a real retail mindset that doesn't always sit at that legacy manufacturer leadership level that sits, you know, down the street in Deerfield Beach. And I think that's a good thing for consumers. Because ultimately, they want to sell cars, but there's, you know, I can remember old stories, you know, Jim Moran would take a slow moving model. And he would bring it into the, you know, their, their, whatever, their regional distribution center at Jacksonville. And he'd put a stripe on it, different wheels on it, different tires on it, and, you know, added equipment and find a way to make it different and appealing.
And the joke was these Northeastern dealers would be calling, you know, their Toyota rep going, I want an XSP tundra. It's like, well, no, that's Southeast Toyota, the only addition.
So Jim Moran, who was the owner of, you know, SCT and Jim Moran and associates, you know, he was a retailer at heart and kind of cared about what this consumers, you know, wanted, he wanted to sell cars.
Jim Moran是SCT和Jim Moran与合伙人的所有者,他真心关心消费者的需求,他希望销售汽车。
And, you know, that still exists to a, to a large degree today. But, but again, so going back to H.T., you know, if I could put everyone on the ground right now, do Google 360. It's a dilapidated facility. It looks like it was built before there was an image program. And I mean, you know, I'll never forget the first day on the ground before we had bought the store. And I'm, you know, watching, you know, 60 customers in the service drive and they've got these, you know, fans above their head that really are doing nothing. They're not pushing any air, right? They're basically like the, you know, ceiling fan you'd have in your home.
No, I know you guys, it's like you should be thrilled when you see that because it's opportunity. I mean, they're probably using that to sell cars, right? You're not paying for the overhead of the store. As you can see, we haven't done much with it, you know, and that's why you should buy here because I'm not, you know, I'm not passing on our building costs. It's like a contractor. It's like finding a contractor, you know, the ones with, like, the white vans, like the broken bumper. It's like, you want them to come because you know, they're not paying for the advertising that they're spending on Google everything.
Right. And, and by the way, none of that's true. When we build a nice new clean facility, none of that's true. No, the reality is we think we can enhance the experience, you know, the throughput's great in that market there. There's a lot of upside on the service side. But, you know, we looked at that deal and, you know, they're selling whenever they were selling 700 800 900 new cars above, and they were selling 150 years. So we go, gosh, what if we could do maybe not one to one right away, but what if we could sell 500 years, you know, they've got that they've got the real estate to do it, the market's there. So, you know, one check, you know, improvement, F and I, and then on the fix side.
So I don't want people to get hung up on it's funny. We have, we do feel calls after acquisitions, like stop driving up the market, driving up pricing. And again, Alan, you know, I joke sometimes that the day that we were closing that deal, I said, I didn't know who was more excited. The Henderson family or Alan Hagg because he knew, he knew in his heart of hearts that that was a record on the blue sky side. But, you know, that wasn't there have been deals where I winced it what we were paying on the on the blue sky side. But not this one because I know there's there's more to serve in that in that market in that store.
So actually, let me ask you this question. Don't you think that by not announcing the blue sky, multiple of the value people are going to assume the worst, and they're going to assume a higher number? Like, I don't care what people know, but you just mentioned, I know you're trying to drag it out. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, I just think that it's already known to be a record sale. And people are calling you asking you why you're driving off the market. Could that work against you? How? How? I mean, I, I mean, when Alan made that announcement, I saw it on social like the day of the sale, you know, I called, I would call Larry, I was sitting with Larry and I was like, did you, did you tell him he could do that? You know, because that's just not the kind of thing that, you know, somebody should have approved it. And Larry goes, yeah, I'm comfortable with that. I'm like, me too. What better, what better promotion for us as a choir? Then we broke the blue sky, you know, we broke the total amount paid for a single point, you know, single store dealership.
You know, and look, there's other secret sauce when it comes to acquisition. I feel like that we have that the public stone. As you've noticed, the Henderson family wanted that name to stay on the dealership. I'm not so sure an auto nation or somebody else could make that agreement could make that commitment to a family like the Henderson. We don't care whose name is on the store. The Morgan name only sits on one of our dealerships. We've never cared. It's not about that. Yeah, so that's a, I think that's a thing that's helped us in acquisition. We've had the, you know, one of the top five list profitable Chrysler Dodge G brand stores in the country. It's right here. It's a Jerry, Jerry, all Jerry Ohm, Chrysler Dodge G brand Jerry, you know, my daughter picks vegetables out of Jerry's garden, twice annually, Dray, his son.
Wait, but it's one of our auditors.
I think you just mentioned something very important. This is interesting because everyone is sort of, you know, zigging to the right on like, Hey, I have to build this large dealer to large business and I have to make sure it's one brand. You're saying one second, I think there's some opportunity here. I'm not going to change the brand and every market I go into. Yes, I'm going to be leaving something on a table, which is building up a consumer, a consumer focused brand that, you know, everyone knows the name of potentially in, you know, Florida or the entire country, but it also provides you with an opportunity or a competitive advantage to make these acquisitions because for that seller that wants to retain the name or that wants to have their name, say, in the market and potentially for the cut for the people in the market, I want to continue doing business with that brand because maybe it means something to them or they've been buying cars their whole life. You offer that. I think that's unique.
Yeah, I mean, it is unique. And you know, I think for us initially, we kind of understood it also as an opportunity or a problem, right? Like in a perfect world, we'd have Morgan on everything. Everyone would understand who our stores are and how our, you know, what our network is grown to be. The reality of life is that you can't do that. So the luxury manufacturers, you know, they dictate that it's city, you know, it's brand and it's it's sitting there. So you think about BMW Tampa, BMW Sarasota, that couldn't be Morgan BMW and having three Morgan BMWs could potentially confuse it.
Yeah, we started kind of bringing that to the import realm. The first store that we acquired as Morgan was called Precision Toyota. And we, you know, and I remember sitting down with Larry and our team like, what are we going to call it? And I was like, Hey, from an organic service, you know, search perspective, what's better than Toyota Tampa bank? I mean, this is back in 2004. You know, paid search is still, you know, hardly a thing, right? Google hasn't been around very long. But I understood a little bit about organic search and just thought that would serve us better. Now you could argue it, you know, six different ways, I think. But the reality is, if there's a digital pivot, you can do it no matter what the stores are named. I think Lithia has shown you that with their driveway product, right? They're going to consolidate that offering under a different digital offering. It doesn't matter what the stores call the Leslie Chapel Honda or whatever, you know, whatever it is. And I tend to agree with that. And again, if it gives you, if it gives a seller a better feeling about the legacy that they spent maybe an entire generation or multiple generations, their family building, why not?
是的,我们开始将这种理念引入进口领域。我们最初收购的第一家商店是Precision Toyota。我还记得和拉里以及我们的团队坐在一起讨论该如何命名商店。我想,从有机搜索的角度来看,有什么比Toyota Tampa bank更好的呢?这是在2004年的事情了。当时付费搜索还不太普遍,谷歌也刚刚成立不久。但我对有机搜索有些了解,认为这样对我们更有利。当然,你可以从六种不同的角度争论这个问题。但实际情况是,如果有数字化转型的需要,不管商店叫什么名字,你都可以做到。我认为Lithia通过他们的driveway产品已经证明了这一点,对吧?他们将把这个产品整合到另一个数字化产品中去。商店叫什么名字并不重要,无论是Leslie Chapel Honda还是其他任何名字。我倾向于同意这种观点。而且,如果这让卖方对他们可能花了一代人或多代人的时间来打造的遗产感到更满意,为什么不呢?
How did you source? How did you source this deal? This is how Andrew's going to deal, which again, if I'm not mistaken, it was the second, it is the second largest Toyota dealer in the country, right?
Correct. Correct. And there's been times I think they've been number one too. They would want me to say that over a long go. But how did you source it?
No, yet. Well, they still, you know, that deal came with the broker. So, you know, Alan Hagg, who's a reputable broker in our space, I'd say he's one of the, you know, certainly the top two between Fred Kerrigan and Kerrigan. Yeah. And great, great guy. You know, again, kind of interesting crawling into his mindset. But when he, you know, when he sits and works with a seller and says, Hey, I've got two or three people in mind, you know, we've worked hard with our relationship with Alan. So we aren't consideration for those kinds of deals. We're well, we're well capitalized. And we feel like we are very organized at acquisition.
You know, again, because of Alan and the Henderson family, we were able to have boots on the ground in that store months before we closed. And when you can get close to the people in the operation and already have those relationships, it does it, it does a tremendous value for those existing staff create synergies. You're hitting the ground running. You're not, you know, making those pivots in 90 days. And they're all different.
So some of them you walk in and the owner tells you, Hey, this, you know, this is my GM, but he's not very good. No, I'm just here. You know, I should have fired him years ago. You guys need to take care of him. You need to wax him. Thanks. This case was very different. It was you need to get to know this GM. You know, he's solid, he's sharp, you're going to like him. And, you know, Scott Zuckerman and just meeting him from kind of day one, that just helped us kind of foster a look, we're not perfect. That's a big, big store.
有些店主会告诉你,嘿,这个是我的总经理,但他不太好。不,我只是在这里,你们需要照顾他。你们需要看好他。谢谢。这个情况非常不同。你们需要认识一下这个总经理。他很靠谱,很敏锐,你们会喜欢他的。我们从一开始就遇到了 Scott Zuckerman ,这帮助了我们培养出我们不完美的一面。这是家很大的商店。
We work extremely hard at acquisition, you know, two calls a week. We've got a checklist 250 deep. We've got, you know, 20, 25 Morgan associates that that service the organization around a large acquisition. And then we put, I think we put, we put too many bodies on that round. But the day we closed, we had 50 associates from other stores helping with transitions with DMS, you know, CRM, all finance systems, DocuPad, they couldn't basically turn around without having health nearby if they knew you have it. You have this entire platform and system, which allows you to, you know, do a pretty pretty seamlessly. It's incredible.
It, it all say this, you know, I think we, we did the math since 2016, where we became kind of an entirely new, different, Morgan. We've done 60% of our acquisitions have come without a broke. So on the other side of answering that question of how do you source deals, its relationships, it's being good stewards of your community, it's being having a great acquisition or reputation. We've never retrated a deal. We've had one that kind of fell apart on the closing table, not really. A week out, they, they wanted to cherry on top and we weren't willing to concede. And that's the only deal in our acquisition history that's ever fallen apart. So when you have that level of trust and reputation, you know, that's certainly something that we offer. And again, we're open minded, you know, we're not waiting at the door, like Darth Vader with 200 stormtroopers ready to come in and, you know, we say it all the time, when we first step into a store, look, we, we, we're not prepared to run this store. You guys are going to continue to run the store. We just want to make it better. And this is how we're going to do it.
You DM'd me on Twitter or now it's X. I think it was like a couple days after the sale, maybe a day after or whatever, we got announced. What was that you were just talking about a little bit about, you know, the process and kind of, you know, I asked you a couple questions, which you'd like, you can, you know, share here. But what was it like for you doing this deal as CEO, just that feeling, you know, the night before siding, like, give us that, you know, really kind of personal feeling of doing such a big deal for the store, kind of getting to the sliver, you even said to yourself, like these are numbers that you're not very used to on an acquisition basis.
Yeah, this was, this one was really special for a variety of reasons. And I don't, I don't know if I've ever shared this with you. But when we went to make our offer, we asked Alan if we could do it to the Hendrickson family in person. And Al Jr. and Al Sr., Al Sr., it actually either gifted or sold the store to his son Al Jr. So Al Jr. was the soul.
I don't think there's any problem with saying that the sole owner of the dealership at the time. And we flew to their home and on a Saturday morning, Larry and I went into the Hendrickson household and sat with Al Sr. and Al Jr. before they'd seen the numbers with the offer ready to present. But we wanted them to know who we were and a little bit about how we felt about us. Because that's a look, it doesn't matter to every seller. Some sellers, it's just, what are the numbers? I don't care what you do with my idea just for whatever reason. It's a shrewd deal. And if you've built something great, I guess you have the right to feel that way.
But the Hendrickson, I think that made an impression on them. Certainly our offer was fair because it was accepted. Yeah, it was surreal. It was surreal because we started with the Toyota store, having it be top two in the United States, having it be on the spot. Did they accept it on the spot?
Yeah, we worked it out with memory service me correct. I don't know. I think we, I thought we shook hands that morning. I don't, for some reason, it's all a blur now. But I thought we knew by the end of the day that they were going to sign the app and move forward. You're probably on the way back to the airport with Larry, looking at each other, shaking hands. We got it. We got it done. Look, what they built was special. It's a market we love and it's a big, it's just a, I joked it was a big dumb asset. I mean, it's, you know, I've heard people say, well, you know, shoot, give me a big volume Toyota store. I couldn't screw it up. That's not true.
Look, I've seen Toyota stores lose money, you know. But at the end of the day, this is just a huge, exciting acquisition. But, yeah, so, get it. You know, look, there's always drama in the closing. I joke, if you were going to write a book about acquisitions, the most interesting chapter would be the negotiation about use car values. Because everyone turns into a used car appraiser the day they're selling their store. And they can either be a, and when you have, you know, 300, 400 vehicles to appraise, you know, that can, I've seen that go a million different ways, but it can be very, very dramatic. I mean, the other assets that you're buying, it's all in the agreement, right? But, you know, typically it's a pretty, that's the only place where it's like sort of like there's a little variance and everyone's kind of, oh, no, this car is worth more. This is less. Especially in today's, you know, dynamic too. We had, you know, we had, you know, used cars over the past three years that were increasing in value, right?
There's guys in the business who think that was normal of fascinating times. But no, that was it. That was a big acquisition. And again, we're, you know, we're not perfect, but we know what we have there. And we've got the guts of something really special. How do you feel about Toyota, right? Like your biggest deal, Toyota deal, how do you feel about the future of Toyota?
I don't think they're wrong. There's some really bright people at Toyota. And you have to, I think you have to ask yourself when we will transition here, talk about EVs. What's the customer's appetite for electric vehicles, right? Because Tesla's done a really good job of selling hundreds and thousands of electronic vehicles in the United States and kind of meeting maybe that existing need and driving more and doing it without, you know, traditional advertising. I mean, hats off. I have, you know, Buku respect to Elon Musk and what he's built to Tesla.
You know, having said that, I think a lot of what is driving the legacy manufacturer towards EVs is governmental, it's policy. And at some point, my fear is we're going to outkick the consumer's appetite here. And I, you know, it's funny, a couple of, you know, a couple of years ago, I was dating a girl, I drove a Model 3, so, so with the same girl. But, you know, I'm like, you know, I've always wanted to drive a Tesla, but I don't want to be the guy at Morgan Automotive pulling up in a Model 3, but, you know, they're coming to the legacy manufacturers. And as soon as I don't feel like I'm taking gross profit out of one of my store's mouths, I'm going to drive one. So that was a, that was December of 21. I hopped in an EV and I've been in it ever said.
So it's, it's a nice one. It's the EQS. It's the Mercedes EQS. I've been in it since December 21, not necessarily Mercedes guy. It just happened to be the one EV we had plenty. And I was it, you know, taking one from a prospective consumer. And, you know, I'll never probably, I'll, I say, yeah, I'll never not. My daily driver will be an EV from here moving forward. Wow. That's a bold statement. Why do you say that?
Well, okay. I think the greatest point of inflection is this. It's got nothing to do sadly with the environment. It's got nothing to do with, you know, saving money, lower maintenance, because it's a non liquid services vehicle. Nothing to do with that. It has everything to do with how it drives. When you drive an EV, you call, you know, high powered golf carts, whatever you want, and you get that instantaneous acceleration, it's tough to go back. And when I'm sitting at a stoplight, and I want to, you know, I'm merging or, you know, I'm making a left hand turn and I want to beat the car in front of me. If I'm in a BMW, you know, X6M, I might have some turbo lag when I mash down that accelerator to beat that car. I might not know what to expect. I might, you know, throw my head into the back seat. And in EV, it's instantaneous acceleration. It's accelerating.
With that said, so you like to instant torque, right? But with that said, why, why do you think Toyota's not making a mistake by being very reluctant to go into a look at anyone can play judge and jury there? I think the question I saw it a little differently. Are they making a mistake in there? What they're saying, I think is is true. You know, I think for now hybrid hybrid until some questions are answered, right? How they're going to recycle batteries? You know, we all know that the mining of lithium decimates that micro environment environmentally. So I think maybe there's some maybe some conjecture. Hey, look, what if we waited a little while? What would be maybe a better time to go full bore into electric? So I think hybrid for a lot of reasons, both environmentally, you know, from a just appeal consumption standpoint, what's good for the consumer? I think Toyota's kind of tried the truth. A lot of things are saying. It was funny because I think you saw me, you know, post on on X recently, you know, Farley kind of for the first time at Ford, you know, retraining some of his sentiment, right? From EV to like talking about hybrid drivetrains.
And it's fascinating because there's some Toyota's you can't buy unless it's a hybrid. And that's been the truth for a long time now. I just I have a lot of confidence in Toyota. I read that they've also maybe are ahead of some of the manufacturers on solid state battery technology. So it's kind of fascinating if they've got what they say they have. You know, by the time they get to the market, maybe they'll have a kind of a second mover killer on the e-b side. You know, I want to add like the way I feel about what I'm seeing with Toyota. And I could be completely wrong. But to me, it feels like they're sort of letting everyone kind of battle between each other. And they're sort of standing on the side in this like very wise strategy, eventually, where they're saying, okay, let's let people kind of battle, lose all their money, you know, make tons of mistakes. And then we'll ride the wave after the kind of the tide is out. We'll see what's the delay of the land, what the market really looks like, what consumers really desire long term. And we'll jump that now. Is that a, you know, will that be a mistake? Will they wait too long? You know, will they continue losing market share due to that as opposed to not having enough inventory? I don't know. But I think that's to me, it seems like that's sort of their playbook. Their sales are off the hook. There's no doubt about that. The man is, you know, better than it's ever been. And so they're sort of kind of, you know, standing on the side and observing.
Yeah, for a lot of reasons, you know, e-b level disruption, it's not Apple versus Blackberry, right? It's different. It's not an overnight transition where somebody can come in and with 18 months, take 80% market share for a variety of reasons. Most of it, because it's just cost prohibitive. You know, that's the problem right now, you know, I see in your reporting and a lot of the reporting out there. And I see it on my own lots, a lot of what the legacy manufacturers are producing. They're making incredible EVs, right? Better fit and finished than Tesla. Tech that's close to on par with what Tesla has, but they're still piling up. Why? All I can say is two things, right? Cost. You know, the cost to acquire an EV, it seems like most of the manufacturers were talking MSRP, price points, 45, 50, 53,000 up, right? That's a lot. That's a lot. That's an expensive vehicle.
If you look at the majority of what, you know, Tesla's market share is now, it's Model Y, Model 3, right? It's on the more affordable side. So I think, you know, that's, that's one thing. The cost is it's a big thing. Yeah. And what's the second? Yeah. And then I think it's consumer appetite, consumer appetite and education. You know, people talk about, well, I've got range anxiety. I'm worried about charging, you know, the infrastructure is not there. Well, why does that matter? Why does that matter? For $600, you can put a level two charger in your garage, right? You can charge just about any EV overnight, 100% on a level two charger. If you work, live, play within 200 miles of your home, you'll never go to a public charger. Why would you? Yeah. You know, and it's in, in two, you've experienced it.
You don't know that. And trust me, I went on my first business trip with my daughter up through Gainesville and Jacksonville and the hotel threw me off the charger, you know, in the middle of the night, and I've got 20% and I got to get back to Tampa. And I'm going, ooh, this is, you know, this is going to be fun. And, you know, thank God, the, you know, the EV go infrastructure that it come to Jacksonville is better than what existed in Tampa because it came later. And they were 350 kilowatt chargers and I charged in 15 minutes and went home. But, and so you've lived it and it is a lifestyle change. You don't understand it. And that's going to take some time, right? And then again, there's other barrier standards related to affordability. But I see that world a little differently and I can speak very effectively on the both sides of my mouth on EVs any, any day. At least they like me to candid.
Now, in terms of your stores, right? Like, are you preparing your stores for a rise in EV sales? Are you sort of kind of waiting and seeing, you know, facility upgrades or training? What does that look like? Yeah, and it's frustrating because, you know, a lot of, you know, I think what people want to talk about is the expense of the charging infrastructure that, and it's kind of being pushed down from the OEM perspective. You know, Ford's had a, had a, you know, obviously a very robust program that got retooled because of the, you know, some pushback from the dealer body, you know, stellantis, you know, we're in the, you know, we're big players with stellantis. We've got 12 stellantis stores. So we're in the process of pushing their EV kind of infrastructure through into our dealerships currently.
Yeah, so we're getting prepared for the future. But again, it's frustrating. So, you know, here we make this commitment with stellantis. And then in the news is, you know, well, Florida's not going to get any four-bikes anymore. So, you know, the Jeep product that's got the, you know, it's, it's kind of a plug-in hybrid. They're all going to go to the, you know, the, the, the Zeb states, California and the zero emission states, and your customer can get one if they order one. So it's like, okay, well, what EV product are we going to get here in Florida to plug into these charges that we're about to invest $6 million? So, you know, there's some level of, you know, frustration anytime somebody's mandating, you know, something, you do need a certain level of charging infrastructure to service and sell vehicles. Don't get me wrong.
Having said that, it's complex, right? Sometimes you're going back to the substation. Sometimes you're just going back to the transformer level, but you're asking a lot of juice, you know, out of facilities that were built in different times.
And, you know, I heard a story the other day, I think, well, I know it was now, it was on your podcast about what the Ford dealer with the diesel generator to power as EV chargers, just so you could get forward lightnings and, and, and, and EV. And it, it just makes you cry laughing.
I think it's very interesting to see how all this unfolds, given, you know, how supplies are ramping up, yet it seems like the, by the numbers demand and by the increasing day supply demand for EVs is dropping again, Tesla being the exception. And like you said, you know, likely almost entirely being driven to certain extent by price, Tesla's able to manufacture those or price at a certain point.
But anytime something doubles, you have to pay attention, right? In new EV sales, I think, have doubled three years straight. That's correct. Or pretty close to it, right? I think it was like one and a half to three or three to six or something that you. Yeah. Yeah.
So, you know, anytime something doubles at that, at that rate, you've got to pay attention. That's not going to happen forever. But how do people, you know, get comfortable with a new way of doing things? Because they watch their friends, neighbors experience it. So it's coming. It's an alternative. It's out there today. And it's, it's pretty good. You can sit around and, and try to poke as many holes as you want into it. But once they've figured out, I think the affordability perspective, then it's on us to help educate our consumers and bring them over.
Now, again, my issue is just, you know, moving in moving too hard and too fast. You're going to leave some consumers behind. And I think some of the legacy manufacturers have been criticized of maybe, of maybe following that line, Mercedes Ford, you have to, you have to be careful.
Do you think dealership profitability has peaked? Or do you think we have more room to run? How do you think about this as you're growing your stores here, you know, you're making acquisitions?
Well, we're, if you're asking, we're same store growth animals. So, you know, we really do focus a lot on, you know, are we growing our throughput? Are we growing our fixed operations, measuring our capacity? How can we do more? How can that particular operation do more? So Morgan's not done growing. We're never done growing.
Has have dealership values peaked from? Yeah, I mean, look, in people in latter 21, 22, they got lucky. They didn't win because they were good. You know, they won because, you know, supply was constrained.
Yeah. You know, I had a GM, I had a GM tell me earlier this year and he was right. He was, you know, we used to run around the showroom and joke, you know, dial for dollars, you know, make that the cold call engagement with our customer base and make it happen. He goes, the customer's been the one dialing for dollars the last two years and it's true, right? You have this hypersensitive environment to MSRP plus pricing, all, all predicated upon supply constraint.
Now, I do think in kind of the post COVID test the world that we live in a real world of winners and losers from a brand perspective. I may be more conscious of that recently. That's just my opinion. There's there are going to be winners and losers as a part of this, you know, this transformation, this move to E.B. There already is. There already are.
You think are going to be the who do you think are going to be the biggest losers? I know the answer. I'm just trying to figure out whether I'm confident enough to just to say it right now.
你认为谁会是最大的失败者?我知道答案。我只是在努力弄清楚自己是否有足够的自信现在就说出来。
Let's say we're going to be the biggest winners. We're going to be the biggest winners. Well, I'll tell you some of the earlier winners in this has more to do with COVID than it does EVs. But Key and Hyundai have been great because they weren't as supply constrained as Toyota at Honda. And they've got really, really good product.
You know, that tell you right, I can't think of a single vehicle in the legacy manufacturer landscape of the past five, six years that has remained as steadily hot as the key to tell you right. And I go everywhere and people want it and they're hard to get from my friends and family and we get as many as we can. And it's just a great, it's a great vehicle. They've done it.
I think it's a terrific. I've also noticed that people from like all kinds of different social classes buying that, which I think is interesting. Like, you know, I've just seen, you know, I've spoken to friends and, you know, kind of relatives and stuff, but you know, some people that are pretty wealthy buy telly rides. And then also, you know, your average kind of, you know, average person, you know, salary job, whatever. Like, I think it's very interesting how this kind of, I call it like the crossover SUV, how it's able to penetrate these different types of consumer segments.
Well, and yeah, and if you're building, is there a better compliment to give a manufactured motor vehicles than what you just did, right? It's a model that people want to see themselves in is aspirational in a sense, right? But it's also something let's face it. When there's an uncertainty in the marketplace, right? People, people tend to care less about the label on the front of their vehicle and what they're spending, right? And they'll play down into something as long as it represents a premium value. And that work premium just gets overused by all the manufacturers and it used to just drive me nuts because I was a bug dealer. I have to listen to that word every day. And I'm like, look, you're trying to play in this space between Cadillac and Chevrolet. And there's nobody in there's nobody who wants to play in that space, right? They want they want the best of the best somehow, you know, he has been able to do that. And when there is uncertainty in the marketplace, a lot of people start, I think they broaden their palate of what they'll consider from a brand perspective. And brand loyalty just seems to me that it's very volatile right now. It used to be that they weren't loyal to the dealership, but they were loyal to the brand. And I don't think that's true anymore. I don't think that's true at all. I think there's a lot of brand volatility. So it's I think we just live in fascinating time. I think you have no choice. I mean, if you need a certain car at a certain price point and you know, one manufacturer doesn't have it or it's too expensive, you're going to go elsewhere.
But do you think that Toyota's been losing market share? Now, we know that their demand is red hot. We know that there are still quote unquote supply constraints for whatever reasons, whenever it's happening there internally. Do you think that's long term going to be detrimental to Toyota? Or do you think that this is just them, whether you know, needing to work under manufacturing or realizing that the company can be just as profitable selling fewer units? How do you think about that?
I've got a lot of confidence in Toyota. I just do, you know, they still offer products at price points that other brands don't. Certainly, if we could get more Toyotas, we'd sell more Toyotas, but the dealership, you know, the dealership body is kind of happy because it's stabilized margin, you know, from a certain perspective. So dealership profitability is still still very well. They make it a great car. You know, I think it's funny. We talked a little bit about kind of their mindset on EV. It sounds to me like in the background, whether it's hydrogen, whether it's solid state batteries and EV, they're not going to miss a step, right? They're just not. They're not going to let the world pass them by. They're just not. Not that they're too big to fail. They're just too smart not to win. And I've got they're too smart not to win. No, they're just they're too smart not to win. They're there. I think from a we used to say, you know, a lot of these manufacturers used to joke all the time, like Volkswagen, I can remember, oh, it'll be five years before Germany figures out that, you know, these window of loaders dropping these jettas or, you know, whatever the issue is, and I can remember Toyota my second year in the business, we've got our GMs going to field input meetings and that data is going back to Japan. I mean, brilliant, brilliant. They just they are so connected to the experience of what they do. I'm not worried about to it.
Do you have any Ford source? We do. We have four. What's your take? I know you mentioned Farley just a little bit. What's your take on this? Like the whole like direction, brand vision, kind of murmurs of like this intermediation or kind of these direct to consumer like what's your general thoughts on Ford?
I've never seen a manufacturer that unless they look unless they're just crushing it, right, unless people are just fighting, you know, hand over fist for the product. I've never seen a manufacturer create that much discontentment from a dealer body perspective and not have to come crawling back at some point.
Do you think it's a lost cause or do you think a change of leadership? No, no, no, no, and I understand a lot of what excites Farley. I think I understand, right? He's trying to, you know, limit production and delivery costs and really trying to create, you know, some efficiencies here and deliver a better experience with a consumer. His heart's in the right place.
I don't look, I don't sit on the the Ford dealer council, but, you know, to me, it seemed like he just could have gone about, you know, certain things differently to try to get there. And, and again, you know, I've talked to a lot of Tesla consumers, you know, that consumer experience has its pitfalls. It's not perfect. You know, I mean, people, if they're buying a new Tesla, they call me on the trade because a lot of the local Tesla stores either put an inferior number on that vehicle or they don't, they don't know what to do with the trade. That's not a great experience. They can't take care of the totality of what you're trying to accomplish.
Yeah. Again, I can kind of see both sides of the issue, but he's, yeah, too strong, too much. And now I will kind of see maybe a little bit of walking back some of that. It definitely looks like, you know, little signals of contracting just a little bit. I think the product's good. You know, I do. My, you know, we finally were able to get a lightning from my brother-in-law. And I was, you know, I've driven one before, of course, but, I mean, I think that product's good. I think the execution on the product, and that shouldn't matter because I don't think every legacy manufacturer has built an EV that, yeah, that they're extremely proud of.
So before we wrap up, I mean, just on this note still with Ford, if you have a message for Jim Farley regarding what you just mentioned, what would it be? Start with what the consumer wants. Start with what a Ford customer wants. And then, and then move forward hand in hand with the dealer body on how to do a better job and take share. And I, again, I think it was the cart before the horse. I think anytime you're telling your consumer, I know what's best for you. And I don't think they were bought in on what's best for them. And there's a high look where every TV consumer wants differently than what's being done right now by Ford. I don't think the consumer is, you know, I don't, again, it's consumer appetite related to EVs. You know, I think hybrid drive trains, I think, yeah, I don't, I don't think every consumer wants to feel like an EV is being, you know, shoved down their throat. I just, I just don't.
And then again, trying to take from a retailing perspective, you know, a certain amount of that entrepreneurial spirit out of, you know, sucking that out of the dealership, they put or tried to put some real constraints. And we did some legislation here in Florida that we supported that kind of, you know, keeps that from affecting us, but really tried to bring the agency model here on the EV side. And I think that's a mistake. I think you meet that dealer that's out kicking his coverage and selling three times what he should in the market. There's a reason. He's treating his customers better. He's doing it at a fair price, right? And he understands the system to get the inventory. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. And he mess with that. Yeah. So that's where some of the dealer discontentment comes from.
But I also think, you know, consumers when, you know, the leader of what they have in their driveway is just EV, EV, EV, EV, EV, EV, and trying to, you know, maybe be like an Elon Musk type type character or could be perceived that way. I think that's danger. I think that's there's some danger in that.
I want to shift topics for one second. One thing that we haven't touched on, which I think you've done very uniquely, is the way you've capitalized the company. I don't think, you know, many private car dealer groups bring in private equity. So I just found that very interesting. I would love if you could just tell us about that experience for you. I'm going to assume that was your first time ever raising capital as well when you brought private equity into the company. So could you kind of walk us through that?
Yeah, we, you know, we had more or less a traditional debts indication. You know, we were building that with multiple lenders. We started Bank of America, Sun Trust, very similar syndication. You're talking about earlier on in the Morgan, the Morgan of the Play Five. Yeah. From outset. From outset. Just how we, you know, who managed our debt? You were raising hand to buy dealerships and typically give us some more details like is this debt like fixed rates, floating grades. How does this work? Well, floating rates, but I mean, that's not exciting for people to hear about. No, but I just think I like that nitty gritty. So if you're typically, that's how typically you've funded these acquisitions. Yeah. Yeah.
And I didn't know what a, you know, a rate swap was back then. So, you know, a lot of this wasn't necessarily in my purview. But we were, you know, you asked me earlier, I can tie two subjects together, you asked me about succession plan. Yeah. So dad and I had sat down and it really started to talk about what a succession plan works, which I think is hilarious because he's not, he's not going to retire. He never needs to retire. There was no, there's no part of the script as long as he's competent where anyone's pushing him out before he is that, he is that important to the fabric of our business. So, we kind of decided, look, maybe instead of a succession policy, we just go for it. Like we just, we just get back to really growing this business. And we had a friend of dads had called them and said, Hey, I want you to take a lunch with a guy named Eric Singer. And Eric's just a friend of mine out of Michigan. He's been in and around the industry. And he's kind of a, I don't know how to say it. He's kind of a freelance M&A guy or something. And we took this lunch and, you know, the friend of dads had been involved, had private equity involved in this business. And Eric wanted to introduce us to some friends of his at Blackstar. And that's, that's obviously a big name. And it's funny, I was looking, I looked it up last night. This was July 2nd, 2015. We had this lunch. And by the end of the year, Blackstone was doing due diligence on our business to get involved and support us with equity. And frankly, they, they just didn't have the bedside manner. They just didn't seem like art type of people, extremely intelligent folks, and great to have those relationships and kind of see a little bit under their curtain.
But we ended up doing business with a smaller house out of Wright, New York named Greenbrier Equity. And their traditional private equity, right? It's, it was an investment, gave us some dry powder to do some acquisitions. And, you know, and then they, you know, it's kind of five year fun life. And, you know, and it is what it is. Problem was we deploy all their capital, they gave us in like a year and a half. So it's like, okay, what do we do now?
Do we sit on our hands for, you know, three and a half years, you know, and just, and wait for the clock to expire? Do we, do we buy them out? And then just go back and start generating, you know, focus on our business and then just reinvest those earnings and acquisition at a later day. You know, what do, what do we do? And we did 19 acquisitions with Greenbrier. And we went out and kind of looking for somebody who could take out that investment and give us more capital to run. And that turned into kind of a unicorn in the capital space, guys named Redwood, Redwood Holdings, Redwood Capital, out of the Baltimore area, a guy by the name of Jim Davis, who was the founder of the largest staffing company in the United States, Allegia's with his cousin, Steve Biscotti, who's the owner of the Baltimore Ravens. And just need people. And it's a small house. And they're through cycle guys. They don't, they don't raise funds. They're not traditional. They're not really private equity. It's really kind of like a family equity office on steroids. And they've just brought a lot of value to our business.
And we've done 35 acquisitions since 2019 with Redwood. We've been the second only. We've also raised capital through a bond race where the second only private auto retail group in the country to do that.
How'd that work? I think at least at that time. Yeah, how'd that work? That was a real education for me. Because that's not, you know, I'm not an NBA guy. And we've reopened that, that bond twice. You know, so I think, you know, whatever the first bite of the apple might have been 700 billion and 300 billion that another two hundred or whatever it was. It's been, it's, you know, we've driven a lot of capital to that, through that bond offering.
But the Redwood guys are, you know, they're great in hot salt. As long as we run a good business, they're not, you know, they're not in playing, you know, armchair quarterback as far as operations. We talked to them all the time. And they were familiar with our space. They're also involved in the RV space. So they, they've got some understanding kind of the franchise retail world. And it's just been a great fit.
And yeah, private equity, when we got involved with Greenbrier, it was very, I think Jordan capital was running around with, with Rick Ford in the Midwest, acquiring some things. So you'd go to any DA, you know, Allen would be having a symposium with, you know, any private equity is part of our business. And it took a while, I think, for the legacy manufacturers to get comfortable with private equity having any kind of equity hold on private dealership businesses.
But really? Yeah, I actually, I mean, I think that like, given there's so many publics, I wouldn't think that that's like a thing. Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, the reality is they had some concerns. And I, and again, when you say private equity, I think you have to be careful because again, I wouldn't put the Redwood guys under that umbrella. But it was, it was quite an education. So to think that it seems like, I may be oversimplifying, but it seems like it feels like a bit more family office capital.
Yeah, it is. And, you know, we, and we, but it turned us into a, you know, that lunch meeting, I was joking with Eric Singer last night, you know, that lunch meeting turned us into a completely different animal. And we restructured our executive team. And, you know, I became CEO, you know, Tom Lohr, our, our COO. I'm trying to think when he came, it would have been maybe a year after he came to the fold as our COO. Yeah, we had to do a lot of kind of preparation for the kind of growth that we, that we saw coming. And then we've been, you know, moving at a clip of about, you know, whatever it is, eight to 10 stores a year.
How was your, how has your role changed throughout all this, right? Like, how is your day? How have your, you know, kind of focus and just general duties? How has that changed for you? Yeah, great, great question. You know, when you're, when you're doing 10 acquisitions, you know, annually, those become very time consuming. So you'll, I almost see like there are sometimes or periods of time where I have, you know, maybe two or three jobs. And then you throw in maybe a week where we're doing bond marketing, right? So it, you know, my life's gotten very fascinating in the sense that there's still the traditional operational role, right? Where we're talking about results, we're measuring, we're managing, we're communicating, you know, what's desired. And we're also trying to, you know, yeah, we're taking the temperature of what's going on in the market. And then we're also, you know, acquiring that's it. That's a, you know, a very time consuming thing from negotiating a deal, negotiating the specifics of a deal, and then kind of articulating how you're, how you're going to take that on. And we have an incredible, we've got two legal guys here, our general counsels, incredible, as far as, you know, handling all the manufacturer approval stuff.
But yeah, our, you know, my life has changed considerably since that 2016 date, because it used to just be about, you know, acquired a store a year and how are you going to make our same stores better. So now it's, you know, it's a little bit more diverse. And we've got, and we've got more stores to pay attention to. So we've had to drive, I think, some efficiencies and think differently about how we do things, because, you know, time is the one asset you can't produce more of, no matter how much you'd like. And we just, we've got an incredible team. We say it every day. It's all people. It's all people. We've got three, we've got three laws that Morgan on a group.
Okay. One is that you, you know, you can't let a good person leave the company, right? If somebody's trying to leave, they've got talent, we want to hear about it, we want to talk about it. Number two is, you know, you can't go to bed at night knowing that you have a customer that's upset, hasn't been handled. And number three is it's all people, you know, so we have, we have great people and that's allowed us to facilitate this level.
Tell me more about the people, right? Like first of all, I think those are good, just great core tenants. And it's so simple yet. So powerful, right? Like don't go to sleep if a customer is upset, right? Like I remember, you know, many nights of being on the phone with, you know, someone at 10 p.m. because just freaks you out. Like why? I don't want to get, you know, that one person, I'll tell other, you know, people about a so bad experience or whatever. But tell me about like, how do you find, you know, your best people? What is that process been like for you?
You know, and it's a mix. You know, now when I look around, we have executive team members that we brought from the outside, you know, we have a tremendous, you know, new HR kind of chief of people that came from one of the public companies. You know, we've got our head of financial services, kind of the guy who runs our F and ideal, you know, he came from a large private cap group. Our CFO was a receptionist in this business when she was 17 years old. She was a single mom at the age of 18. And we hired her as our first new hire controller in our first dealership, Toyota Tampa Bay. So she's gone from, you know, running a store that netted, you know, on a good month, a $100,000 to, you know, being the CFO of a nearly $9 billion revenue business, which is incredible.
你知道的,这是一种混合。你知道的,现在当我四处看看,我们拥有了一些从外部引进的执行团队成员,你知道的,我们有一位非常了不起的人力资源总监,她来自一家上市公司。你知道的,我们有一个金融服务部总监,负责管理我们的理财和理想团队,他来自一个大型私募股权集团。我们的首席财务官在17岁时曾是这家企业的前台接待员,18岁时成为了一位单身母亲。我们在我们的第一家店铺,Toyota Tampa Bay,招聘她作为首位新员工控制器。所以她从每个月净利润可达10万美元的店铺经营者,晋升为一个近90亿美元营收的企业的首席财务官,这太不可思议了。
What's that? I mean, what's that like that process seems, you know, crazy for someone like, you know, just coming back or to CFO? Like, what has that process been like for her? And she's had to change the way she lives. I mean, you know, she's had to hire people to do things that she enjoys doing. I would say her ability to grow has a large, a large amount to do with the fact that she's not really a traditional typical CFO. She understands every nook and cranny of the car business, you know, and it probably you have to ask her, but it probably hasn't always been easy.
Yeah, this wasn't, you know, when we hired her to commandeer, you know, at the single point toy at a store, you know, this wasn't in the offering, right? Hey, you're gonna, you know, you're gonna oversee, you know, hundreds of millions and, you know, bond raise this that it's, I think, been a good education for our COO. Tom Moore came through an acquisition, our third acquisition. He was an operator. He actually left us for a period of time. Ran his own store. He used to run a platform of stores. And, you know, over time, it was clear that whatever we gave Tom, he didn't lose anything. And it was, you know, strange. Sometimes people can go from a single, you know, point environment where they're a micro manager and you put him into a larger and they just don't know how to build the same levers that they did when they had a smaller focus of responsibility. And Tom's been someone who's been able to kind of grow with us.
Now we have an incredible team. And again, it's a mix of people that have come from the outside, Josh Luter, who's the head of our fixed operations. He was our first service director, Toyota Tampa.
You know, what I'm seeing and what I think about this business is that, especially if we're on the independent side, you know, non franchise, it seems like while there may be very minimal or no barriers to entry to becoming a dealer, the real barrier to entry is the people because it's, like you said, especially you're running a very decentralized business. These people are not compensated, you know, when they're compensated because of their good looks, right? It's because they're bringing value at the end of the day.
And so it seems like everything you're saying, it's very, very non traditional, which is, you know, I guess it's every business, but it's neat to hear it from you because, you know, you've sort of been in the game for so long that you've picked up these gems along the way. And so you've assembled these team of superstars that you just can't do overnight, right? Like, it's not like you just came out of nowhere. And within 12 months, you know, you've assembled a team. I mean, it takes time.
And I think it's, it's incredible. We, we spend six hours a week just interviewing folks, even when we don't have positions available, just making relationships, how to understand the talent set. Yeah, work.
Look, if we hire somebody from the outside to run a Morgan store, we're going to miss three times three X more with with somebody from the outside than somebody we grow internally. But I promise you back in 16, when we went from acquiring one store to acquiring six or eight a year, we had to start leaning in from the outside because we out kicked our coverage on our bench. Now we look, we've got a talent bench where so it's, you know, it's like spinning plates, right? We're developing our talent internally, but we're also kind of, you know, consistently opening up those lives communication and making relationships with really great people in our business that that frankly, frankly, we think we have a differentiated, we have something to offer them to the others don't. So we work really hard on our people. It's very time consuming and it's, but it's everything.
What do you think about independent stores? You know, I know you guys had independent stores. I think you divested. I mean, is that a space that you mentioned used cars all time, right? But will you get back into sole independent stores? I don't know. I don't think so. Now granted, you know, one of those two experiences was a bad location and we were like the fourth to fail there. So I don't know if we had some delusions of grandeur or what.
You know, that's, that's hard because I feel like, you know, the typical retail landscape calls you a successor failure based on a 30 day period of business. And I feel like in the independent, like, you know, right now our used car business is not great. It's just, it's, you know, we're running more percent margins. It's, you know, it's, it can only get better, but it's been a really tough to navigate. And I think you'll see, you know, the quarterly earnings reports, a lot of publics probably haven't had a unique experience from what we've had. But the independent space, man, it's hard. So I would say first and foremost, you really need to look at how you judge your success on a longer period of time. I'm not saying a monthly financial statements worthless. I'm just saying, you know, when you're carrying 200 used cars and the books dropped a percent to half. And, you know, you had your best manager was on a vacation into Heaney for two weeks. And you've got your record, you know, I mean, look at, I mean, look at Carvana, you're in the commodity business. They were ramping up at maybe the worst possible time ever, right, running right into COVID. And I mean, you're, you're kind of a commodity straight. And you don't have that offset. You can, you can have some offset, but you don't have that offset that the traditional, you know, manufactured dealerships at, you know, I think if there's one thing I could tell your listeners, it's that if you look at our revenue, 17% of our revenue is accounted from fixed operations and F&I, right? So service parts, body shop, F&I, only 17% of the dollars we generate comes from those worlds. It's 60% of our gross profit contribution.
60% of your profit contribution is from fixed operations, yet on a top line and F&I. Yeah. But from a top line, it's only 17%.
你盈利贡献的60%是来自固定运营,而在整体收入以及金融与保险方面,仅占17%。
Yeah. So the bottom line here, and I think it's the right way to look at it is that, you know, margins are just much better on service on F&I. And margins are much worse on use car, you know, to use car sales themselves, parts and stuff like that.
It's your insurance policy. You know, we say that all the time. And because our founder and, our co-founder and chairman spent his past life understanding the value of that non-worancy customer, we tend to do that better than most. And that's, that's a huge part of our insurance policy.
There's a lot of things you can't control that factor into new and used car sales, right? dealership values, consumer sentiment, interest rates, right? And in those things can confound you in a very quick matter of time. If they affect your consumers, they affect you.
And what, you know, what's wild to me is when I got into this business, you know, average cost to sale and use car was benchmarked at 15 grand. And it was 18 grand. And it was 22 grand. You know, I just told you what our use car margins are. But I think our average, you know, cost of our excuse to average retail transaction price and use cars, like $33,000 last quarter. It's incredible how it's risen.
And it's pinching up, you know, the consumers, it's pinching the consumer. And it's coming down just tiny. I think it's down like 4% year over year or something like that, maybe even less. Yeah. But we're still so, you know, we so underproduced last couple of years. It's, you know, it's hard to, it's hard to imagine it coming down meaningfully, like, you know, double, double digits or an accelerated timeframe. So agree. And you think that would be good for dealers, but it's still, it's still a challenge.
My friend, I think we covered, I think we covered a lot. And this was amazing. And I really appreciate you sharing everything and also just getting a chance and opportunity to document your story. I think I'm not sure how much you've told that story. You know, it's just getting into the business growing from tires plus to the dealership business. But just, you know, really incredible journey you guys have been on. And you know, really happy that you came on.
And I want to ask, you know, where can people learn more about you and Morgan Arbery? I'm pretty visible. I'm, you know, I'm on Instagram, I'm on Twitter. Excuse me, ex. Brett AM, Brett AM. So Brett Ashley Morgan Brett AM TPA, which is Tampa. Morganautogroup.com. Yeah, there's, you know, I'm around. And I love, I love engaging, you know, with, with industry folks and consumers alike. So, you know, reach out. There it is.
我想问一下,你知道人们可以在哪里了解更多关于你和摩根·阿伯里吗?我相当有公开度。我在Instagram上,也在Twitter上。对不起,是Brett AM,Brett AM。所以是Brett Ashley Morgan Brett AM TPA,也是坦帕。还有Morganautogroup.com。是的,你知道,我经常在场。我喜欢和业界人士和消费者一起互动。所以,你知道,可以联系我。就是这样。
Really enjoying it. Brett, thanks for coming on my brother. All right. Take care. Thank you. Barque. All right. Hope you enjoyed that episode. Please give the podcast a rating. Consider subscribing to the show and check the show notes for links to what we talked about. Thanks for tuning in. I'll see you guys next time.