Base 44 vs Bolt.New vs Lovable - Best AI Coding Tool
发布时间 2025-03-17 19:01:37 来源
这个视频评测了 Base 44，一个全新的零代码应用构建平台，并将其与已有的平台如 Bolt.new 和 Livable 进行了比较。评论员对 Base 44 处理更复杂功能的能力表现出特别的兴趣，因为 Bolt.new 和 Livable 在这方面有时会不足。
视频首先介绍了 Base 44，展示了注册和开始创建应用的简易性。然后，评论员分享了他使用 Base 44 创建一个“Stand Store”克隆的个人经历，这是一个用于销售 PDF 等数字产品的平台。 使用 Base 44 创建的应用能够轻松上传和下载简历，展示了一个功能性的 PDF 商店。 虽然它没有自动集成用户或支付功能，但被认为是一个很有希望的开始。
评论员强调了 Base 44 的用户友好界面，特别是应用创建过程中清晰的、循序渐进的流程。他强调了轻松上传内容和在应用中选择元素的能力，并指出与某些平台上的错误体验相比，它运行顺畅。
评论员关注的一个关键领域是 Base 44 中的工作区功能。他指出分析的重要性，它可以让用户跟踪应用流量并识别哪些应用正在获得关注。他还强调了自定义域名集成对 SEO 的价值。提到了通过 Stripe 进行的支付集成，这简化了向应用添加支付功能的过程。该平台还提供基本的用户管理，简化用户身份验证。添加代码的功能也存在，但仅限于付费计划。 这是为了允许程序员自定义应用程序。
他讨论了 Base 44 的定价结构，并指出它与 Livable 和 Bolt.new 相似。视频描述中将包含一个比较表，概述每个平台的每月消息限制。
为了提供一个平衡的比较，评论员随后在 Bolt.new 和 Livable 上重新创建了相同的“Stand Store”应用创建提示。 他指出，他最近发布了一门关于 Bolt.new 的课程，旨在帮助用户通过该平台构建的应用盈利，这得益于他在市场营销和 SEO 方面的背景。 该课程将涵盖基本功能并介绍实时构建。
展示了 Bolt.new 上的测试结果，强调了生成应用在视觉上吸引人的设计，但它缺乏功能性方面，尤其是在添加和销售产品方面。 虽然该网站看起来很有吸引力，但功能不够强大。 评论然后展示了使用 Livable 进行测试的结果。评论员承认，更清晰的提示可能会产生更好的结果。 生成的应用看起来像一个功能齐全的网站。 但是，虽然它似乎有不同的产品页面，但它们并没有真正发挥作用。 以用户身份注册的能力是一个积极的方面。 尽管该提示没有导致所需的 PDF 上传功能，但总的来说，Livable 应用被认为是令人印象深刻的。
回顾回到了 Base 44。 评论员得出结论，Base 44 特别适合初学者，因为它易于使用且能够创建功能性应用程序。 Bolt.new 因其在视觉上吸引人的设计而受到赞扬。 另一方面，Livable 被定位为一个更强大的平台，用于构建功能齐全的网站。 他建议所有三个平台都值得尝试，以确定哪个最适合个人需求和偏好。
This video reviews Base 44, a new no-code app builder platform, comparing it with established platforms like Bolt.new and Livable. The reviewer expresses particular interest in Base 44's ability to handle more complex features effectively, an area where Bolt.new and Livable sometimes fall short.
The video starts with an introduction to Base 44, showcasing the ease of signing up and initiating app creation. The reviewer then shares a personal experience using Base 44 to create a "Stand Store" clone, a platform for selling digital products like PDFs. The app created with Base 44 allowed for easy uploading and downloading of a CV, demonstrating a functional PDF store. While it didn't automatically integrate user or payment features, it was deemed a promising start.
The reviewer emphasizes the user-friendly interface of Base 44, particularly the clear, step-by-step process presented during app creation. He highlights the ability to easily upload content and select elements within the app, noting that it worked smoothly compared to some buggy experiences on other platforms.
A key area of interest for the reviewer is the workspace features within Base 44. He points out the importance of analytics, which allows users to track app traffic and identify which apps are gaining traction. He also underscores the value of custom domain integration for SEO purposes. Payment integration through Stripe is mentioned, which simplifies adding payment functionality to apps. The platform also provides basic user management, simplifying user authentication. The ability to add code is also present, but only on paid plans. This is designed to allow coders customize the app.
He discusses the pricing structure of Base 44, noting that it is similar to Livable and Bolt.new. A comparison table outlining the monthly message limits for each platform will be included in the video description.
To provide a balanced comparison, the reviewer then recreates the same "Stand Store" app creation prompt on Bolt.new and Livable. He notes that he recently launched a course about Bolt.new, aimed at helping users monetize apps built on the platform, drawing on his background in marketing and SEO. The course will cover basic features and introduce live builds.
The results of the test on Bolt.new are presented, highlighting the visually appealing design of the generated app, but it lacked functional aspects, particularly in terms of adding and selling products. While the site looks appealing, it is not functional enough. The review then shows the results of the test with Livable. The reviewer acknowledges that a clearer prompt might have yielded better results. The generated app looked like a fully-functioning website. However, while it seemed to have different product pages, they were not really working. The ability to register as a user was a positive aspect. While the prompt didn't lead to the desired PDF upload functionality, overall, the Livable app was deemed impressive.
The review goes back to Base 44. The reviewer concludes that Base 44 is particularly suited for beginners due to its ease of use and ability to create functional apps. Bolt.new is praised for its visually appealing designs. Livable, on the other hand, is positioned as a more robust platform for building full-fledged websites. He suggests that all three platforms are worth trying to determine which best suits individual needs and preferences.
中英文字稿 
Alrighty, righty. So base 44 is a new challenger in town. So let's have a look at it today. It is something similar to livable but on bolt.new. So we'll we'll test it up against those two tools as well. But actually, there's a couple of interesting features that at that base 44 has that I would really like to see in bolt and livable. So this is what it looks like when you sign in, right? So you just write type the app that you want to create. Of course, and I like I'm quite interested in this like deep coding. So it's like going to do a lot more work with the features. Right? So that is one of the problems with livable and bolt, right? It struggles with kind of deep features, not deep, but like features actually creating something that works, right? I was creating an app there a while ago and you know, took me ages trying to get up to work in bolt, but I got it to work in livable after a while. I was like adding API keys, all of that stuff, you know? So this will be quite interesting to test out yourself.
好的，那么现在有一个新的挑战者登场，那就是base 44。今天我们就来看看它。它和livable在bolt.new上有些相似。所以我们也会把它和这两个工具进行对比测试。不过，base 44有一些特别有趣的功能，我真的希望bolt和livable也能具备。在你登录之后的界面是这样的：你只需要输入你想创建的应用即可。当然，我对这个所谓的深度编码很感兴趣，因为这意味着它会处理更多的功能。这正是livable和bolt的一个问题所在，它们在处理深入的功能时显得有些困难，不是很深入，但就是真正创建一个有效的功能这个点上。我之前在bolt上尝试创建一个应用，花了很长时间才搞定，但在livable上最后还是成功了，包括添加API密钥之类的。所以这个工具还挺值得自己去试试看。
And I just tested out a quick little app here. So let's have a look at this. So I just I create a stand store clone, right? Stand store is a platform that you can sell digital products with fully functional abilities to sell PDFs. So this is what I got here. So it's a PDF store, right? And yeah, I just uploaded my CV here just to test it out a little bit. So yeah, you can just download it here. It didn't automatically like add users or payments, stuff like that, but it looks pretty nice. It works very similar to bolt, and livable here you can see. So you can just upload stuff, select element, this works very well. Look, you can see it just works really nicely. And some of them other ones can be a little bit boogie sometimes. So I like that. That's very cool. And yeah, you just keep adding whatever their suggestions here.
我刚刚测试了一个小应用。我们来看看这个应用吧。我创建了一个 Stand Store 的克隆版。Stand Store 是一个能够出售数字产品的平台，具备完整的功能来销售 PDF 文件。这是我创建的一个 PDF 商店。我上传了我的简历来进行测试。在这个平台上，你可以下载它。虽然平台没有自动添加用户或支付功能，但界面看起来不错。它的工作方式与 Bolt 和 Livable 非常相似。在这里，你可以上传文件，选择元素，这一切都运行得非常顺利。其他一些平台有时可能会有小问题，但这个平台表现得非常好，我很喜欢。你可以根据建议继续添加内容。
One thing I like here is also the steps, right? So it actually went through step by step. Always a good thing to do with AI, I think. So it created a PDF. And yeah, I published it and it looks looks really nice and actually works. So quite happy with that. It has the store and then the dashboard. Obviously I would probably add payments, but a super easy way to just get started selling digital products like right. It just didn't want prompt, but obviously you could just change this around. But I think the real key with this is the workspace here. So let's have a look at some of these features. All of these things I want in my tool right is analytics really important. I want to see how many people are going to my apps, right? Because if I can create 10 apps, then I can see, okay, one, and you know, one of them is getting way more attraction than the other one. It's getting traffic coming from whatever SEO or from Twitter or wherever it's coming from.
我喜欢这里的一个地方是它的步骤，对吧？它确实是一步一步地进行的。我觉得这对AI来说是件好事。然后它生成了一个PDF。我把它发布了，看起来非常不错，而且确实能用，所以我对此感到很满意。它有商店和仪表板。我当然会考虑添加支付功能，不过这是一个很简单的方法来开始销售数字产品。虽然它是基于一个提示生成的，但显然你可以根据需要进行更改。我认为这里的关键是这个工作区。让我们来看看这些功能。我想在我的工具中拥有的功能之一就是分析，这非常重要。我想了解有多少人使用我的应用程序。因为如果我能创建10个应用程序，然后我可以看到，哦，其中一个明显比其他的更受欢迎。它的流量可能来自SEO、Twitter或其他渠道。
Okay, you can see it's got 17 visits just me really. But I've just been clicking around the right. But you can see that that would be super valuable to have analytics to this stuff. Okay, the main you definitely want to have your own custom domain if you're actually creating something right because yeah, for SEO purposes you want an exact match keyword domain if possible, right? Payments. So they do have this payment integration where you just add the stripe. So it's all set up apparently to work, right? So you just add your stripe page and then it will add the button and really, really good. So and then saves your users. So that's quite interesting if you are adding users, whereas you know, with bolts and lovable, we would have more a super base integration right. So I think this is actually easier for beginners right to have all this stuff right there.
好的，你可以看到这里只有17次访问，实际上都是我点出来的。但是你可以看出，有这样的分析数据会非常有价值。如果你真正在创建某些东西，你绝对会想要有自己的自定义域名，因为从SEO的角度来说，如果可能的话，你希望有一个精确匹配关键词的域名。关于支付，他们确实有一个支付集成，你只需要添加Stripe就可以了。似乎所有的东西都设置好了，可以正常工作。你只需要添加你的Stripe页面，然后它会添加按钮，这真的非常好。而且还能保存你的用户信息。如果你在添加用户，这就很有趣了，而在使用Bolts和Lovable时，我们会有更多的超级数据库集成。我认为对于初学者来说，拥有所有这些功能其实更简单。
Yeah, so really good. You can also add the code. That's only in the paid plan though. You can see even the way it looks here, it's like doesn't look so complicated for a non-coder, right? You can just and change the different files here. Sometimes when you look at a code editor and IDE, it looks quite difficult. So yeah, you can add APIs and your settings here. So a really, really interesting app. It seems to have very similar pricing to I mean, the prices are quite similar to lovable and bolts. So you've got your $20.50 and $100. That's the same as lovable, I think. So yeah, let's have a look at lovable. So I will compare this in the in the description down below because yeah, it's going to take me. I'm going to have to ask JGPD compare monthly messages between the three.
好的，非常好。你也可以添加代码，但这只在付费计划中才行。在这里你可以看到它的界面，看起来对非编程人员并不复杂，对吧？你可以在这里轻松更改不同的文件。有时候，当你看到代码编辑器和集成开发环境（IDE）时，它看起来相当复杂。所以，你也可以在这里添加 API 和你的设置。真的是一个非常有趣的应用。这个应用的价格似乎和 Lovable 和 Bolts 非常相似，好像都有 $20、$50 和 $100 的计划，和 Lovable 是一样的。所以，让我们来看看 Lovable。我会在下面的描述中进行比较，因为我要问 GPT 来比较这三者的月信息量。
So I'll leave that down in the description to see you can see exactly a comparison table. I won't be able to put a table on YouTube, but you know what I mean, I'll try to make it clear. So you can see the different pricing, right? Okay, so to be fair to the other ones, let's do the exact same prompt in bolt and lovable and we'll see what we get from each of these. So let's see, I'm comparing them. I think that would be quite interesting to do, right? So lovable is bringing up this one and we also have bolt doing that.
所以我会把这个放在描述中，这样你就能看到一个比较表格。我没法在YouTube上放一个表格，但你明白我的意思，我会尽力让它清晰。这样你就能看到不同的定价，对吧？ 好的，为了公平起见，我们用同样的提示在Bolt和Lovable中试一下，看看各自的结果如何。我认为这样比较还挺有趣的，对吧？所以Lovable提供了这个结果，而Bolt也有类似的表现。
So while let's doing that, I have a new course, right? I'm bolted out new. So it's kind of like make money with bolted out new, right? And the reason that I wanted to do this is because you know, it's so easy now to actually create little apps and there's just tons and tons of things that you can do, right? So I want to really help you to actually make money out of that. My background is in marketing, right? And SEO. So I know that you know, you can make tons of these apps, but like if you're not going to make any money, then it's kind of pointless.
所以在我们这样做的同时，我有一个新课程对吧？我推出了一个新的课程。这个课程有点像通过新产品赚钱，对吧？我想做这个的原因是因为现在创建小型应用程序非常容易，而且你可以做的事情特别多。所以我真的想帮助你从中赚钱。我的背景是在市场营销和搜索引擎优化方面。因此，我知道你可以制作许多这样的应用程序，但如果你无法从中赚钱，那就没有意义了。
Well, I don't know if that's what I want to do is make money out of these. So I'll leave a link to this. It's really cheap. I'm not, I don't want to spend, you know, don't want you to spend tons of money on this. Basically, there's kind of like an introduction part to help you use bolt better. And then what I'm going to do is go through live builds. So like just the use cases, right? So it's like different types of websites, different types of apps, all of that. So every new every week will have like a new live build and we'll talk about it. I will get that together.
好吧，我不知道自己是否想通过这些来挣钱。因此，我会留一个链接，价格非常便宜。我并不想，也不希望你们在这上面花费很多钱。基本上，这包含一个帮助你更好使用Bolt的介绍部分。接下来，我将进行一些实时构建，例如不同类型的网站、应用程序等使用案例。每周都会有新的实时构建，我们会一起讨论。我会把这些整理好。
Right. So let's see what we have here. Loveable is still going here as is bolt. Okay, so bolt is actually just given us a whole plan here. So let's go. Okay. So now it's going to start doing the coding. Okay. So bolt is ready and loveable teams to be creating a super op of some for. I don't know. Let's see what it is. But this is the kind of colors. I like the little and features there that you can choose there. So it has different things.
好的，那我们来看看这里有什么。Loveable 仍在继续，而 Bolt 也是如此。好的，Bolt 实际上给了我们一个完整的计划。所以我们开始吧。现在它要开始编程了。好的，Bolt 已准备就绪，而 Loveable 团队似乎正在创建一个超级应用。我不太清楚是什么，看看会是什么。不过这种颜色我喜欢，还有那些小功能，可以在那里选择。它有很多不同的东西。
Let's see. We didn't really get a way to add our products though. Did we? So they did actually give us, you know, more options here. But what'd it be nice? I suppose to add my products here. I don't see a way I can do that. It's going to dark mode. Okay. That's cool. And let's see what happens if no. Okay. That doesn't work. Okay. So no, it did. It added something to the cart. But all right. So just looking at it in the full preview. Yeah. I mean, it's a good start. I suppose not very functional.
让我们看看。我们好像还没有找到添加我们产品的方法，对吗？不过，他们确实给了我们更多选项。但如果能在这里添加我的产品，那就好了。我找不到这样做的方法。哦，它可以切换到深色模式，这还挺不错的。让我们看看如果……不，这样不行。不过，哦，系统确实把一些东西添加到了购物车里。好吧，总之，看看完整预览，我觉得这算是个好的开始，但功能性不算太强。
I do find that's kind of the thing with bolt is like often it will just look nice. I kind of like the designs that they have, but it's not really functional. So obviously we would have to keep going through here or exported to something else if it's not working for you. So yeah, lovable is still going. Obviously I don't really care about, oh, we have built unsuccessful. Not so good. I don't really care about the time. Obviously, and I just want something good.
我发现，Bolt的设计通常看起来很漂亮，我也挺喜欢他们的设计风格，但实际上并不是很实用。所以如果你觉得不合适，我们显然得继续寻找其他解决方案或导出到别的东西。总之，Lovable项目还在进行显然，我不是特别在意时间，我们构建没有成功，结果不太好。但实际上，我只想要一个好的结果，这才是最重要的。
All right. So we have the lovable one is ready. Took me a couple of goals. There was errors there. Actually, yeah, when lovable really actually works. Sometimes I just open up like two tabs and then just give it to, you know, you also need to think a bit more about the prompt. I didn't give a great prompt here. Did I? So one thing that's very cool is all of these pages. Look, we've also, we've got the cart working to check it. Well, I don't know if they're working yet, but you can see this is properly done here.
好的，所以我们已经准备好可爱的那个了。我试了几次才成功，其中有一些错误。实际上，当'可爱'这个概念真的有效的时候，有时我会打开两个标签页，然后直接操作。你也需要多考虑一下提示。我这次的提示并不太好，对吧？不过，有一个非常酷的地方是所有这些页面，看，我们还有购物车功能可以检查。我不确定它们是否已经正常运作，但你可以看到这里处理得很到位。
Okay. So yeah, I mean, that looks really nice. I like that. And right, and our products here. So it looks more like a full website definitely does. I wonder if these probably don't go in here. Okay. Well, actually they do work. I doubt this goes somewhere. What? Okay. Yeah, we got four or four. And okay, but we could prompt that to get it better. I don't really mind that. That's fine.
好的。那么，是啊，我是说，这看起来真的很不错。我喜欢这样。对，现在我们这里还有我们的产品。所以这看起来更像是一个完整的网站，确实是。我在想这些大概不应该放在这里。好吧，实际上它们确实起作用。我怀疑这会去到哪里。什么？好的。是的，我们遇到了404错误。但是，我们可以调整一下让它更好。我不太介意，这没关系。
And I really like this. Actually, it looks very, very nice. And let's see what happens. Okay, we actually got a new pages, right? So yeah, well, that's a bit mixed up, but we have different products there. So let's see, when I can actually register here, that's pretty nice. Okay, so I am like a registered user here. You can see my name up here. So I think it would be cool if I could create my PDF. I think that was what I really meant by this store.
我真的很喜欢这个。事实上，它看起来非常非常好。让我们看看会发生什么。哦，我们真的有了新的页面，对吧？虽然有点混乱，但我们有不同的产品。所以，看看我什么时候可以注册，这真不错。好，现在我是这里的注册用户了。你可以在上面看到我的名字。我觉得，如果我能创建自己的PDF，那就太棒了。我想这才是我对这个商店真正的期望。
So yeah, I don't think we actually, okay, we have a cart. That's pretty cool. Let's see if we can add them to the cart. Okay, I can add it to the cart. Yeah, okay, I can proceed to check it. Okay, it's pretty nice. But I suppose I also need the part to add. So it didn't do that, but overall pretty, pretty nice, right? So let's go back to base 44. So I like these little things as well, just to be able to share, you know, copy the link. It's easy to just create that app that's actually working, you know, I can already upload.
所以，我觉得我们其实，并没有，哦，我们有一个购物车。这挺酷的。我们来看看能不能把它们加到购物车里。好的，我能加到购物车。是的，我可以继续结账。这还不错。不过，我想我也需要添加部分内容。所以它没做到这一点，但总体来说还是挺不错的，对吧？所以我们回到基于44的那个地方。我也喜欢这些小功能，只要能分享，比如复制链接。这样创建一个真正能用的应用程序也很简单，我已经可以上传了。
So for simple apps, I think this is probably for newbies, probably the best one to actually use. I like bolts for, you know, little things with, I like the designs a little bit. This, uh, lovable, I suppose, is also more for just real websites, really, really impressive as well.
对于简单的应用程序来说，我觉得这可能是给新手用的，可能是最好的选择。我喜欢bolts，因为它适合一些小东西，我也喜欢它的设计。这个，我想，可能更适合真正的网站，也非常令人印象深刻。
So yeah, I just think we're in a crazy world now where we can just, you know, get our ideas into existence, right? That's it for this video. I definitely recommend trying them all out, right? It's not, not a big deal to try them all out and see what works best for what you want to do.
所以，是的，我只是觉得我们现在生活在一个疯狂的世界里，我们可以把自己的想法变为现实，对吧？这就是这段视频的全部内容。我真的推荐你全部去试一试，没什么大不了的，试试看哪个最适合你想做的事情。
And yeah, check out the bolt new course. If you want more information about building and trying to monetize this type of product.
当然，看看这个全新的课程吧。如果你想获取更多关于构建和尝试将这类产品变现的信息。