The "Motley Fool Money" podcast episode, hosted by Chris Hill with analysts Seth Jason, James Early, and Shannon Zimmerink, covered a range of financial news and market opinions, blending serious analysis with lighthearted commentary.
The show kicked off with September's retail numbers, which showed the first increase in same-store sales since August 2008, up 0.6% against a forecast of a 1.1% decline. Despite the positive headline, the analysts were largely skeptical. Seth Jason pointed out that a Labor Day holiday shift likely moved back-to-school spending from August to September, benefiting low-end retailers like Zoomies. He also noted conflicting data, with consumer credit still contracting, making it hard to believe people are spending more while borrowing less. James Early and Shannon Zimmerink echoed the caution, questioning the profitability of these sales and noting the increase came from "catastrophically low levels," prompting a sarcastic "golf clap" for the modest improvement.
Next, the discussion turned to "Dr. Doom," economist Nouriel Roubini, who predicted a further 10% fall in the housing market and warned about commercial real estate losses. James Early found the 10% forecast "forgettable," suggesting Roubini was aiming for a "Dr. Realist" moniker. He agreed that commercial real estate is a significant issue, with many loans "not marked to market," posing a risk to regional banks. Seth Jason, while agreeing that "everyone borrowed too much," questioned the direct link between commercial and residential real estate prices. The panel lightened the mood by debating Roubini's nickname, eventually settling on "Dr. Doom" due to his past accurate predictions, or "Dr. Playa/Love" due to his perceived social success.
The conversation then shifted to technology, starting with reports of Twitter negotiating with Google and Microsoft for a data licensing deal to integrate real-time Twitter feeds into search engines. Seth Jason believed this would be most beneficial for Twitter, which is "flailing around looking for something to monetize." James Early was skeptical of the widespread appeal, questioning "who really wants to search some guy's twit?" but conceded it could have niche value for hedge funds tracking trends.
Google's CEO Eric Schmidt's deposition admission of overpaying for YouTube ($1.65 billion vs. an internal valuation of $600-700 million) was another hot topic. James Early expressed confusion over Schmidt's logic, joking about his negotiation skills, and dubbed YouTube "the most important but least relevant video outfit on the planet." He argued that premium content had migrated to Hulu or Vimeo, leaving YouTube with largely un-monetizable "grassroots content." Seth Jason saw it as Google acting like a venture capitalist, throwing money at a potential "blow up" success, especially since Google Video was struggling. Shannon Zimmerink pointed out the massive cost implications of YouTube's "1 billion views a day."
Dell's upcoming Android-powered smartphone with AT&T sparked a debate on its potential threat to Apple's iPhone. Seth Jason dismissed it, comparing it to the forgotten Dell MP3 player and suggesting AT&T might welcome it to relieve iPhone network congestion. James Early was equally dismissive, using an "iPod to Zune" analogy and emphasizing Apple's "huge moat" with its App Store, predicting it would "kill Research in Motion's BlackBerry." Shannon Zimmerink agreed, citing Apple's phenomenal growth in smartphone market share.
Amazon's decision to lower Kindle prices and launch an international version was largely viewed positively. Seth Jason saw it as extending the product's reach and fending off competitors like Sony, Barnes & Noble, and potential Apple e-readers. He highlighted Harvard Professor Clay Christensen's point about the Kindle's ability to allow authors to update content, making it a disruptive force for publishing. Shannon Zimmerink concurred, noting it strengthens Amazon's position against emerging competition.
Finally, McDonald's plan to open a restaurant in the Louvre museum drew a mix of humor and resignation. Seth Jason offered another sarcastic "golf clap" and joked about the Vatican being next. James Early considered it a "low-risk thing" for McDonald's, noting the French secretly love the brand and pointing out the Smithsonian already hosts a McDonald's. Shannon Zimmerink revealed that France is the second-largest McDonald's market outside the U.S.
The show concluded with a humorous segment about Nobel Prize nominations for economics, followed by the "Stocks on Radar" segment. Shannon Zimmerink revisited **Moody's**, citing Warren Buffett's reduced stake, a recent stock price pop without significant news, and ongoing regulatory uncertainty. James Early recommended **Accenture**, a consulting company with a recent 50% dividend hike, high return on equity, and a strong backlog. Seth Jason, following the retail discussion, suggested focusing on **low-end retailers** like Aeropostale, which cater to customers seeking value.