In an "emergency podcast" of All In, Emil Michael, the Undersecretary of War for Research and Engineering, joined Chamath Palihapitiya, Jason Calacanis, and David Friedberg (Sacks was absent) to discuss recent geopolitical events and the burgeoning defense tech landscape.
The discussion kicked off with the US and Israeli joint military action against Iran, which followed the removal of Venezuelan leader Maduro. Jason noted that President Trump’s stated goal was not regime change but to stop terrorism and the development of ICBMs and nuclear weapons. Emil emphasized that the Iran operation was projected to be "weeks, not months," focused on disarming terror groups, and would not involve protracted "boots on the ground" like Afghanistan. He attributed the efficiency of recent operations, such as the swift removal of Maduro, to a highly trained military, advanced technology, and revised "rules of engagement" that allow more tactical discretion to achieve objectives.
Friedberg and Chamath expanded on the strategic implications, suggesting these actions create "maximal leverage" for the US in upcoming negotiations with China. Friedberg highlighted China's reliance on oil from Iran and Venezuela, arguing that disrupting these supply chains could give the US a stronger bargaining position. Chamath pointed to China's slowing GDP and potential internal instability as factors that might drive them towards a conflict like an invasion of Taiwan. He posited that by cutting off oil supplies from Iran, Venezuela, and potentially Russia, the US is strategically hemming in China, aiming to prevent a larger global conflict. Jason praised the potential outcome, suggesting that freeing the people of Venezuela and Iran from autocracy would be a significant achievement for democracy.
The conversation then shifted to the future of warfare, particularly the role of AI and drones. Emil stated that "drone on drone warfare, robot warfare" is the future, citing the Pentagon's "drone dominance program" and the increasing use of inexpensive, one-way attack drones. He explained that AI is crucial for controlling drone swarms, automatic target recognition, and operating in complex scenarios like hypersonic missile defense (e.g., "Golden Dome"), where human reaction times are insufficient. He acknowledged concerns about AI reliability but argued that specific scenarios dictate risk tolerance, and in certain contexts, AI can be safer and more precise than human-controlled operations.
Economically, the impact of the Strait of Hormuz closure on oil prices and the maritime insurance market was discussed. Friedberg explained how the US government, through the International Development Finance Corporation (DFC), stepped in to provide political risk insurance after traditional markets (like Lloyds of London) ceased coverage. This move was seen as brilliant, potentially leading to the reshoring of maritime insurance to the US.
A major segment of the podcast focused on the Pentagon's decision to deem Anthropic a "supply chain risk" and cancel its $200 million contract. Emil detailed how Anthropic, a beneficiary of the Biden AI executive order, had embedded its technology within various US military commands. However, their contract terms restricted the use of their AI models for sensitive military applications (e.g., kinetic strikes, satellite movement), citing concerns about "fully autonomous weapons" ("murder bots") and "mass surveillance."
Emil argued that the Pentagon's mission necessitates "all lawful use" of technology, and Anthropic's restrictions were impractical, especially in critical situations. He revealed that an Anthropic executive had allegedly inquired whether their software was used in the Maduro raid, raising alarms about their intent to enforce these terms and potentially jeopardize military operations. Chamath underscored the broader risk this poses: companies relying on a single AI vendor face uncertainty if that vendor's "political perspective" or "philosophy" dictates how the technology can be used. He drew parallels to "de-platforming" but on a foundational technology level. Emil added that other AI companies like Grok, Google, and OpenAI are more willing to support "all lawful use" cases, making redundancy crucial for the US government.
Regarding defense tech and the industrial supply chain, Emil highlighted efforts to reduce dependency on China by domesticating critical components (rocket motors, batteries, critical minerals). He discussed the Office of Strategic Capital's $200 billion lending authority to achieve this. He also acknowledged the growing defense tech venture capital market but stressed the need for these new companies to secure significant contracts to prove their viability and attract further investment, shifting towards "mass, low-cost" systems rather than expensive, large-scale platforms. Emil concluded by noting that while China has undertaken the greatest military buildup in history, the US still maintains superior capabilities in areas like submarines and space, though vigilance is required to prevent the gap from narrowing.