The Sovereign Individual - Mastering the Transition to the Information Age - YouTube - PR Report #4 The Sovereign Individual::Chapter 4 - The Last Days Of Politics
发布时间:2021-10-26 13:59:17
原节目
以下是“公共关系报告”第四集的内容摘要,重点讨论了《主权个人》第四章,题为“政治的末日:圣母教会的衰老与保姆国家的相似之处”。主持人 Puebl Rising 深入探讨了作者对500年前一场历史性的大政治转变的分析,以阐明当前从工业时代向信息时代的过渡。
作者詹姆斯·戴尔·戴维森和威廉·里斯-莫格勋爵认为,我们正在经历一个类似于15世纪末发生的阶段性变化,其标志是改变中世纪社会的技术进步。他们使用“大政治”的概念来识别被忽视的、改变暴力逻辑的潜在变革原因。这种理解旨在帮助个人驾驭正在将权力从民族国家转移出去的“新的权力革命”。
本章题为“政治的末日”,因为作者预测传统政治的消亡,传统政治被视为对暴力控制的争夺,而火药革命带来了暴力的更高回报。他们指出,腐败、道德沦丧和效率低下是一个系统进入最后阶段的信号特征,并将15世纪末的教会与当今的民族国家进行了类比。
五百年前,教会是所有事情的核心,就像今天的政治家和政府一样。教会,就像今天的民族国家一样,运行了大约500年。教会饱受腐败(如出售赎罪券)、不道德(如神职人员的私生子)和效率低下(如下层神职人员乞讨住所)的困扰。今天,民族国家也面临类似的指责,政治家经常被视为腐败,系统被视为臃肿且效率低下,这体现在持续的税收增加和政府过度干预。
15世纪末的大政治转变,是由技术进步驱动的,促使社会从由教会主导的农业封建社会转变为越来越批判教会的工业、商业和探索社会。这场转变是由火药武器、印刷机和改进的航运技术催化的。
火药武器增加了暴力的规模和回报,导致对封建制度的下行压力,并改变了个人与其统治者之间的关系。它允许君主购买更多的武器,增加火力的规模,并增加暴力的回报。随着财富可以更具战略性地部署,体力变得不那么重要。
印刷机提高了识字率,侵蚀了中世纪象征性解释的世界观,为批判性思维、因果推理,并最终为科学革命铺平了道路。它促进了关于新市场和投资机会的知识传播,分散了知识,并为批评教会提供了渠道。很像互联网和比特币等技术正受到压制。
改进的航运导致了更多的探索、新的贸易路线以及拥有可部署资本的商人阶级的出现,从而带来了新的机会,例如资助军队、间谍船或前往新世界的探险。这个阶级不太支持教会,更喜欢投资这些新企业。
现代世界诞生于新技术、新思想和黑火药的混乱之中。火药武器和改进的航运破坏了封建主义的军事基础,与此同时,新的通信技术也破坏了它的意识形态。印刷机帮助揭示了教会的腐败,这是一个被社会置于中心地位的社会反而对其不屑一顾的矛盾社会。这与一个将政治置于一切中心地位的社会对政治家和官僚的幻灭有着明显的当代相似之处。
该分析有助于巩固人们的理解,即一场重大的大政治转型正在进行中。就像位于社会中心的统治系统一样,民族国家政府是腐败、不道德、臃肿和效率低下的。技术的快速发展也改变了暴力的逻辑,金融再次发生转变。现在,团体和个人可以对像民族国家这样的大型实体构成真正的威胁。
This is a summary of Episode 4 of "The PR Report," focusing on Chapter 4 of "The Sovereign Individual," titled "The Last Days of Politics, Parallels Between the Senile Decline of the Holy Mother Church and the Nanny State." The host, Puebl Rising, delves into the authors' analysis of a historical mega-political shift from 500 years ago to illuminate current transitions from the industrial to the information age.
The authors, James Dale Davidson and Lord William Reese-Mogg, argue that we are undergoing a phase change similar to the one that occurred around the end of the 15th century, marked by technological advancements that transformed medieval society. They use the concept of "megapolitics" to identify hidden causes of change that alter the logic of violence and are often overlooked. This understanding aims to help individuals navigate the "new revolution of power" that is shifting power away from nation-states.
The chapter is titled "The Last Days of Politics" because the authors forecast the death of traditional politics, seen as a struggle for control over violence, fueled by the increased returns on violence brought about by the gunpowder revolution. They point out that corruption, moral decline, and inefficiency are signal features of a system in its final stages, drawing parallels between the Church at the end of the 15th century and today's nation-state.
Five hundred years ago, the Church was central to everything, much like politicians and governments are today. The Church, like today's nation-state, had a roughly 500-year run. The Church was plagued by corruption (like the sale of indulgences), immorality (like the clergy's illegitimate children), and inefficiency (like lower clergy members begging for homes). Today, nation-states face similar accusations, with politicians often seen as corrupt and the system as oversized and inefficient, evidenced by continual tax increases and government overreach.
The mega-political shift at the end of the 15th century, driven by technological advancements, spurred a transition from an agricultural, feudal society dominated by the Church to a society of industry, commerce, and exploration increasingly critical of the Church. This transition was catalyzed by gunpowder-based weaponry, the printing press, and improved shipping technology.
Gunpowder-based weaponry increased the scale and returns of violence, leading to a downward pressure on feudalism and a shift in the relationship between individuals and their rulers. It allowed a monarch to purchase more weapons, increase the scale of firepower and increase the returns on your violence. Physical strength becoming less relevant as wealth could be deployed more strategically.
The printing press increased literacy, eroding the medieval worldview of symbolic interpretation and paving the way for critical thinking, cause-and-effect reasoning, and eventually the scientific revolution. It facilitated the spread of knowledge about new markets and investment opportunities, decentralized knowledge, and provided an outlet for criticism of the Church. Much like the internet and technologies like Bitcoin are being targeted for suppression.
Improved shipping led to increased exploration, new trade routes, and the emergence of a merchant class with capital to deploy, leading to new opportunities such as funding armies, spy ships, or expeditions to the New World. This class was less supportive of the Church and preferred to invest in these new ventures.
The modern world was born in the confusion of new technologies, new ideas, and the stint of black gunpowder. Gunpowder weapons and improved shipping destabilized the military foundation of feudalism, even as new communications technology undermined its ideology. The printing press helped reveal the corruption of the Church, a society that was paradoxically held in low regard by a society that placed religion at the center of everything. It is a paradox with an obvious contemporary parallel in the disillusionment with politicians and bureaucrats in a society that places politics at the center of everything.
The analysis helps to cement the understanding that a major mega-political transformation is underway. Much like the ruling system at the center of society, the nation state governments are corrupt, immoral, oversized and inefficient. The rapid evolution of technology has also shifted the logic of violence and finance is shifting again. Now groups and individuals can pose a legitimate threat to a large-scale entity like a nation-state.