This is a summary of Sarah Kirchberger's talk on Mao Zedong.
Kirchberger emphasizes that Mao is a consequential figure of the 20th century, one of the most important in Chinese history and a significant political and military theorist. She clarifies that acknowledging Mao's importance is not an endorsement, but rather an accurate reflection of his lasting global impact.
Mao's theories were employed by enemies of the United States to seize control of failing states from within and impose dictatorial rule, and that Mao is also a brilliant psychopath.
The presentation draws from Stuart Shram's collected works of Mao, highlighting sections previously omitted. Kirchberger's approach is to assemble Mao's scattered ideas into a comprehensible framework for analysis, useful for understanding complex situations.
Kirchberger positions Mao as a triangle builder, referencing Clausewitz's framework of people, military, and government. Unlike traditional military theorists focused on state-to-state warfare, Mao's approach deals with building power from the ground up, constructing a shadow government to eventually seize control. This model proved attractive to many decolonizing nations after World War II, particularly those with agricultural and underdeveloped economies, as opposed to Russia's industrial base.
Kirchberger outlines Mao's actions after winning the Chinese Civil War, including imposing a social revolution involving the elimination of entire social classes. She notes that civilian deaths during this period surpassed total deaths in World War II, underscoring the brutal nature of Mao's regime. The Great Famine, caused by policies implemented during the Great Leap Forward, resulted in 40 million deaths. Mao's decision to continue exporting food despite widespread starvation highlighted his prioritization of government income over the well-being of the population. Despite these atrocities, Mao remains a hero to many Chinese, who view him as the one who reunified China and ended the era of humiliation.
Kirchberger contextualizes Mao's theories within the wars he fought, starting with the collapse of the Qing Dynasty in 1911 and the ensuing multilateral warfare among warlords. The Nationalist and Communist parties initially formed a united front to eliminate these warlords, but Chiang Kai-shek later turned on the Communists in the White Terror. The Long March resulted in massive Communist losses, but the Japanese invasion of Manchuria and subsequent aggression forced a second united front between the Nationalists and Communists. Mao understood he was fighting a civil war within a regional war, and eventually a global war.
Kirchberger presents a framework for analyzing Mao based on Clausewitz's definition of great leadership, emphasizing intellect and courage. She assesses Mao as a propagandist, a social scientist (focused on data analysis), an operational military leader, and a grand strategist.
Mao started as a propagandist, understanding the power of words and the importance of propaganda in gaining power. He focused on messenger, message, and medium, using propaganda posters, activists, and foreign journalists to disseminate his message. The message itself was kept simple, using matching slogans and poetry. Mao utilized political mobilization, education, and drama to spread his ideology.
Mao the social scientist focused on understanding the peasantry through extensive data collection and analysis. He concluded that a small percentage of the population owned most of the land, leading to his call for revolution and land reform. By determining class status through a violent land investigation movement, Mao sought to incentivize the majority of the population to support the revolution.
As a military leader, Mao believed political power grew out of the barrel of a gun. His military strategy involved luring the enemy into favorable terrain for annihilation. Base areas were strategically important in defensible locations. His military services were split to guerrilla forces versus conventional forces.
Finally, Kirchberger discusses Mao as a grand strategist, integrating elements of national power like the peasantry, propaganda, land reform, base areas, and diplomacy into a coherent strategy.
Kirchberger also highlights the importance of understanding the role of base areas, which are important to building loyalty and gaining momentum in a larger campaign.
Kirchberger concludes by exploring the dualities in Mao's thinking, going all the way back to Chinese yin and yang theory, that there are aspects of all dualities that are in constant tension with each other. This tension is understood to be used to the practitioner's advantage.
Mao, despite his many successes, was an abusive and violent leader who had little or no concern for his own personal safety, as well as the people that he governed.